A Bowie-Dick test checks air removal and steam penetration in a pre-vacuum sterilizer; it is not a sterility test and it is not a substitute for a biological indicator. It belongs to cycles that start with a vacuum stage, usually the first cycle of the working day before any load is released. The
Bowie-Dick test packs, six per pack are the format most clinics use for that check.
What does a Bowie-Dick test actually detect?
It detects residual air. The pack is built so that steam has to travel through a defined mass of porous material, and the indicator sheet in the middle changes colour only where steam reached it. A uniform change means air was removed and steam penetrated evenly. A patchy or central-lag change means air was trapped.
That is a statement about the machine and the cycle, not about the instruments. A passing Bowie-Dick tells you the vacuum stage is working well enough for a porous load to be penetrated; it does not tell you that any particular load was sterilised.
Which cycles need one?
Pre-vacuum cycles, which includes the Class B benchtop machines used in most dental and medical clinics. Those machines remove air with a vacuum stage before steam enters, and the Bowie-Dick test is the recognised check that the stage worked.
Gravity displacement cycles do not need a Bowie-Dick test, because they have no vacuum stage to check. Running one in a gravity cycle produces a result that says nothing useful about air removal, and treating a poor result there as a machine fault leads to unnecessary service calls.
Where a clinic runs both machine types, the check applies to the pre-vacuum machine only, and the log should make that obvious rather than leaving a reader to infer it from the model number.
| Question | Bowie-Dick test | Biological indicator |
|---|---|---|
| What it detects | Residual air, steam penetration | Spore kill in the challenge position |
| Which machine | Pre-vacuum only | Any steam sterilizer |
| Frequency | First cycle of the day | Each day the sterilizer is used in Ontario |
| Result | Pass or fail on the indicator sheet | Growth or no growth after incubation |
| Proves sterility | No | No, it validates the cycle |
When in the day should it run?
The usual practice is the first cycle of the day, before any load is released, so a machine fault is found before instruments are processed rather than after. Some policies also require a run after a major repair, a chamber cleaning or a long shutdown.
Running it mid-day after a failed load is not a substitute for the daily check, but it is a sensible extra step when the cause of a failure is being investigated. Record it as an additional test rather than overwriting the daily entry.
Where a machine sits idle over a weekend or a holiday closure, run the test on the first cycle back rather than assuming the last result still applies. The check costs one pack and one cycle, and it catches the gasket and pump problems that tend to appear after a shutdown rather than during steady use.
How is the result read and recorded?
The pack is opened after the cycle and the indicator sheet is compared with the manufacturer reference. The result is pass or fail, with the cycle number, the machine, the time and the initials of the person reading it. Photographing the sheet is a useful habit because the colour change fades and a photograph is easier to defend later than a recollection.
A fail is handled as a machine event: the sterilizer comes out of service, the cause is investigated, and the load that would have run is held. A fail is never recorded as a "borderline" result, because a borderline reading is a fail with a softer word on it.
How does it relate to the biological indicator test?
The two answer different questions. The Bowie-Dick test answers whether air was removed; the biological indicator answers whether the cycle killed spores. Both are needed, and neither replaces the other.
In Ontario the biological indicator expectation for dental sterilizers is a test for each sterilizer on every day it is used, not a weekly test. The weekly baseline that circulates online is the CDC and AAMI ST79 position in the United States, and applying it to an Ontario practice under-tests the machine.
What should a clinic stock to run the test?
The test packs themselves, a log with fields for the sheet result, and a service contact for the day a fail happens. Packs are single-use and have an expiry date, so order them in a quantity that turns over inside the shelf life rather than in a year of supply.
A clinic running one test a day needs roughly 250 packs a year, which is about 42 packs of six. Ordering in that rhythm keeps the lot number current and makes it easy to trace a suspect batch if several machines fail in the same week.
Related reading
sterilization monitoring collection; what a Bowie-Dick test does in a gravity cycle; what each indicator proves; wholesale and multi-site ordering Reselling? become a distributor.
Take the paperwork with you: print the sterilization log sheet, pre-fill a week of cycles with the log generator, or ask a sterilization compliance specialist to review how the records line up with the load sheets.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a Bowie-Dick test required in a gravity displacement sterilizer?
No. The test checks air removal, and a gravity cycle has no vacuum stage to check.
Does a passing Bowie-Dick test mean the load is sterile?
No. It means air was removed and steam penetrated the test pack. Sterility is supported by the biological indicator and the load record.
How often should the test run?
The first cycle of the working day in a pre-vacuum machine, before any load is released, plus after repairs or a long shutdown if policy requires it.
What do I do when it fails?
Take the sterilizer out of service, hold the load, investigate air removal and the vacuum stage, and record the failure with the corrective action and the retest.
CliniEco Medical is a licensed medical device establishment (MDEL #35334).