What Is a Process Challenge Device and Why Does It Matter?

A process challenge device is a holder that places a biological or chemical indicator in the position that is hardest for steam to reach, so the test represents the worst case in the load rather than the easiest. Without one, an indicator can sit on the chamber floor, pass easily, and tell you nothing about the wrapped instrument set beside it. The device is the difference between a test that measures your process and a test that measures your luck.

Any clinic running daily monitoring needs one. A 24-hour self-contained biological indicator placed loose in the chamber is not a process challenge; the same vial inside a device placed in a dense load is.

CliniEco 24-hour biological indicator vials prepared for placement inside a process challenge device

What makes a device a process challenge device?

Three properties. It creates a physical barrier that steam must penetrate, such as a narrow lumen, a folded pack or a sealed capsule. It holds the indicator at the end of that path, so the indicator experiences the condition at the hardest point. And it is used consistently, in the same position, so results can be compared over time. A device that is assembled differently each day produces results that cannot be compared.

Device type What it represents Typical use
Commercial disposable PCD A defined challenge, reproducible between runs Daily biological monitoring on wrapped loads
In-house pack with indicator Same packaging as the real load Sites without commercial devices, if assembled identically
Helix test device A narrow lumen, typical of hollow instruments Class B dental sterilizers with hollow loads
Bowie-Dick test pack Air removal and steam penetration, no biological result Daily check on pre-vacuum units

Why does placement matter more than the device?

A device in an easy position is an easy test. The purpose is to put the challenge where the load is densest, usually the lower centre of the chamber or inside a representative instrument set. A device placed near the door, on the top shelf or on the chamber floor tests a location that sterilizes easily and will pass even when part of the load does not.

Placement also has to be repeatable. If the device moves between loads, a positive result cannot be attributed to a position or a cycle. Mark the position in the chamber and use the same one each day, or rotate on a written schedule if you want to test more than one position.

What does a device not tell you?

It does not tell you that every item in the load was sterile. It tells you that the hardest position reached the condition the indicator measures. If the load is badly constructed, with packs touching walls or a chamber overloaded, the device may still pass while other positions fail. That is why loading discipline and the device work together.

It also does not replace the chemical indicator on each pack. The device is a test of the process; the pack indicator is a check of each pack's exposure.

CliniEco dry-block incubator receiving biological indicators from process challenge devices

How should a clinic document the device?

Record the device type, its position, the indicator lot and the readout time on the load line. If the device is reused, record its condition and the manufacturer's reuse limit; many commercial devices are single-use, and reusing one changes the challenge it represents. If you assemble your own, write the assembly method on a card at the packing bench so every shift builds it the same way.

Keep the device with the same sterilizer and do not move it between units. A device that travels between machines mixes the record and makes a unit-specific problem harder to see.

How does this connect to the daily monitoring requirement?

In Ontario dental practice, a biological indicator is expected for each sterilizer on every day it is used. That requirement is about frequency; the device is about validity. A daily test without a challenge device can satisfy the frequency and still fail to detect the problem you are testing for. Use both: one indicator per sterilizer per day, inside a device, in the hardest position.

For a lab or a multi-site group, the same principle applies at higher volume. One device per load, or per cycle type if loads differ, gives a result that can be compared across sites. A group that uses the same device and the same position at every site can compare rates; a group that improvises cannot.

What should a clinic do when the device result is positive?

Quarantine the load, trace the items, and check the device before the sterilizer. A device assembled incorrectly, an expired indicator or a device placed in the wrong position can produce a positive result that says nothing about the machine. If the device and indicator are sound, move to air removal, loading and steam quality, then call service.

Related reading

Download the printable sterilization log, or build one with the log generator. Ask a Compliance Specialist at our consultation desk. Ordering for a clinic, lab or care home? Wholesale and multi-site ordering covers account setup for institutional buyers. Start with a 24-hour biological indicator 25-pack when you set up a device routine. Reselling? become a distributor.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a process challenge device?

A holder that places an indicator at the hardest point for steam to reach, so the test represents the worst case in the load rather than an easy position.

Can I make my own process challenge device?

Yes, if you assemble it identically every time and document the method. A commercial disposable device is more reproducible and is the usual choice for daily monitoring.

Where should the device be placed in the chamber?

In the densest part of the load, typically the lower centre, and in the same position each day so results can be compared.

Does a process challenge device replace the pack indicator?

No. The device tests the process at the hardest position; each pack still needs its own chemical indicator to show exposure.

CliniEco Medical is a licensed medical device establishment (MDEL #35334).

Already working with clinics? Become a regional representative.