How Often Are Process Challenge Devices Required? A Canadian Compliance Reference

A process challenge device goes into the sterilizer every time a biological indicator is run, because the PCD is what makes the biological indicator test meaningful. The indicator tells you whether the cycle killed the challenge organism; the PCD makes sure the challenge is placed where the cycle is hardest to deliver. So the frequency question is really the biological indicator question: in Ontario, the RCDSO requires a biological indicator for each sterilizer on every day it is used — daily monitoring, not weekly — and for each type of cycle that is used. Each of those tests goes inside a PCD. The weekly baseline is the CDC / AAMI ST79 standard in most US states, which is a different jurisdiction's rule and not the Ontario requirement.

If you are assembling the monitoring line, a compliance kit that bundles the elements is the simpler way to keep the daily routine complete: the pre-vacuum compliance kit and the gravity cycle compliance kit cover the cycle types most clinics run.

What is a PCD and what does it add to a biological indicator test?

A PCD is a holder or assembly designed to present the biological indicator in a worst-case condition. It might be a commercial disposable device with the indicator sealed inside a small stack of material, or a defined tray configuration chosen to match the hardest load your clinic processes. Either way, its job is to stop the steam from reaching the indicator as easily as it would if the indicator were simply laid on the chamber floor.

Without a PCD, a daily BI test can pass every day while a dense instrument pack in the same chamber fails. The PCD removes that blind spot, which is why the two are treated as one test rather than two separate requirements.

CliniEco Medical Class 4 dual-indicator sterilization pouches, 200-pack, used for packaging and integrity control in a sterile processing suite

How many PCDs does a clinic need per day?

One per sterilizer per day of use, and one per cycle type used. A clinic with two sterilizers, one running pre-vacuum cycles and one gravity, and both in use that day, runs two tests — one for each sterilizer — with the indicator matched to the cycle type. Where both sterilizers are the same type and run the same cycle, the tests are still per sterilizer, because a failure is specific to a machine.

Does every load need a PCD and a biological indicator?

Not every load. The daily biological indicator is a machine-level check on each day of use. Separately, many jurisdictions expect loads containing implants to be monitored with a biological indicator and held until the result is available — that is a load-level requirement, and it is the reason implant loads are commonly quarantined. Check the standard that applies to your setting, because dental, laboratory and hospital expectations differ.

Monitoring element How often Where it goes What it confirms
Chemical indicator Every load Outside the pack, and inside where the pack configuration requires it Exposure to the process — not sterility
Biological indicator in a PCD Each day the sterilizer is used, and for each cycle type used Hardest-to-sterilize position per the loading diagram Microbial kill under worst-case conditions
Bowie-Dick test Pre-vacuum cycles, on the schedule your jurisdiction and manufacturer specify Empty chamber, front-bottom position Air removal and steam penetration
Physical parameters Every cycle Chamber instruments or cycle printout Temperature, pressure and time reached during the cycle
Load release record Every load Monitoring log The decision to release, and who made it

Where should the PCD be placed?

In the position that is hardest to sterilize for your load configuration — commonly the front-bottom of the chamber, or wherever the sterilizer's instructions and your validation work identify as the worst case. It should not be placed on top of the load or in the middle of an empty shelf, because that tests an easier condition than your real loads present. Whatever position you choose, keep it consistent and note it in the procedure so the test means the same thing every day.

What should the log record for each PCD test?

Enough that a reader can reconstruct the test without asking questions: date, sterilizer identity, cycle type, indicator lot number and expiry, incubator used and its temperature, the control result, the test result, the time the result was read, and the operator. Where a PCD is reused, add a note of when it was last inspected, and follow the manufacturer's limit on reuses — a damaged PCD stops being a challenge device and becomes a formality.

Pair of blue nitrile examination gloves laid out flat for a care or housekeeping task

What happens when a PCD test fails?

Treat it as a failed biological indicator, because that is what it is. Stop using the sterilizer, review the loads processed since the last passing test, and follow your recall procedure — which means deciding which loads were released, which can be retrieved, and what happens to instruments that were used. Then investigate: the sterilizer, the loading configuration, the indicator lot and the incubation conditions. Record the finding and the corrective action, and do not return the unit to service until a repeat test passes.

The most common cause of a PCD-positive that turns out not to be a sterilizer fault is handling: an indicator read late, incubated in the wrong block, or processed without a viable control in the same batch. That is why the control line on the log is not optional paperwork.

Related reading

Browse our sterilization monitoring supplies.

Frequently Asked Questions

How often is a process challenge device required?

Every time a biological indicator is run. In Ontario, the RCDSO requires a biological indicator for each sterilizer on every day it is used, and for each cycle type used, so each of those tests is run with a PCD.

Can a biological indicator be run without a PCD?

The indicator can be processed on its own, but the test then no longer represents a worst-case challenge and can pass while dense packs in the same chamber fail. The PCD is what makes the daily test meaningful.

Is a weekly biological indicator enough in Canada?

In Ontario, no — the requirement is daily, on each day the sterilizer is used. The weekly baseline is the CDC / AAMI ST79 standard applied in most US states, which is a different jurisdiction's rule.

Does every load containing implants need a biological indicator?

Many jurisdictions expect implant loads to be monitored with a biological indicator and held until the result is available. Confirm the rule that applies to your province and setting, since expectations differ between dental, laboratory and hospital practice.

CliniEco Medical is a licensed medical device establishment (MDEL #35334).

Keep PCD and indicator results on one sheet using the sterilization log sheet generator, and print the daily monitoring log for the bench. Working out which tests apply to your sterilizer type and settings? Ask a sterilization compliance specialist to map the schedule for your cycles.

Sterilization compliance hub · What is a process challenge device (PCD)? · How often should you run an air removal test? · A daily sterilization log checklist for Ontario dental clinics

Setting up a monitoring routine for a clinic, laboratory or care home? Apply for the 24-hour biological indicator 25-pack to trial the format, or open a wholesale and institutional supply account for case pricing on indicators, PCDs and compliance kits. Reselling? become a distributor.

Already working with clinics? Become a regional representative.