Test Pack Selection and Placement: Where a Process Challenge Device Belongs in Which Load Type

CliniEco Bowie-Dick test pack, ISO 11140-5 Type 2, 6-pack, with accept and reject reference for a daily vacuum check

Two decisions decide whether a process challenge device tells you anything: which challenge the device actually presents, and where it sits when the cycle runs. Get the first wrong and the test measures an easy load. Get the second wrong and it measures the easiest corner of the chamber. Neither mistake shows up as a failed indicator — both show up as a passing test that would have passed anyway. This article maps the device types to the cycle and load types they are meant to represent, then maps placement to load state, because the same device belongs in a different position in a full load, an empty chamber, and an immediate-use cycle.

Quick Summary: A process challenge device is defined by the resistance it creates, not by the indicator inside it, and AAMI TIR31:2008 exists specifically to help facilities select and use one. Placement is driven by load state rather than by habit: in routine monitoring the device goes into a fully loaded chamber at the cold point, normally the centre of the load toward the front; for gravity-displacement testing, qualification testing and immediate-use cycles it goes on the bottom shelf of an otherwise empty chamber, normally front and bottom near the drain. Ontario adds a timing rule that changes the device's composition: the first reprocessing cycle of the day carries a biological indicator plus a Type 5 or Type 6 chemical indicator, while later cycles carry a Type 5 or Type 6 indicator only. The Bowie-Dick pack is a separate test with a separate placement: horizontal, on a cart or shelf over the drain, in an empty preheated chamber.

The pack format that most Canadian clinics already stock is the daily vacuum check: a Bowie-Dick test pack that complies with ISO 11140-5 as a Type 2 indicator. It answers one question — whether air was removed — and it is not a substitute for the biological challenge described below.

What is a process challenge device actually challenging?

AAMI TIR31:2008 describes a process challenge device as an assembly that mimics the challenge presented by the product and packaging in a sterilization process, providing a repeatable challenge by representing the worst-case conditions for the sterilizing agent to penetrate. The document exists because, at the time of publication, no standard defined the performance of these devices or provided methods to evaluate them. It therefore does two things: it sets out how a facility assembles a device that suits its own loads, and it lists what to ask a manufacturer about a commercial device before relying on it (AAMI TIR31:2008).

That framing matters for selection, because it makes the device load-specific. TIR31 treats steam, ethylene oxide, dry heat and hydrogen peroxide sterilization in separate sections, each with its own description, device types and recommended application, and it adds extended cycles and ozone. It also draws a boundary that is easy to miss: process challenge devices used in liquid chemical sterilization are outside its scope. If a clinic moves to a liquid chemical process during an equipment outage, the TIR does not tell it which challenge to use — the sterilant manufacturer's instructions do.

The indicator inside the device is a separate choice from the device itself. A biological indicator makes the challenge quantitative: it shows whether the conditions killed a known population of resistant spores. A chemical indicator makes it immediate: it shows whether the parameters were reached, while the load is still in hand. TIR31 covers both forms, including chemical-indicator devices used for the Bowie-Dick test in dynamic-air-removal sterilizers.

Which device belongs to which cycle and load type?

The selection rule is easier to apply when it is read as a question about the hardest item you routinely process, not about the sterilizer. ST79 asks facilities to choose a representative package or tray for compact sterilizers — the one considered most difficult to sterilize among those most frequently processed, containing the items normally present, with multiple layers of dressing material, a large metal mass, or a mix of both counting toward difficulty (ANSI/AAMI ST79:2017, clause 13.7.3.1).

Load or cycle type What the device should be Indicator it carries Where the requirement comes from
Wrapped instrument trays, routine monitoring A standardised challenge pack or a commercial equivalent, or for compact units the representative tray that is hardest to sterilize Biological indicator plus a chemical indicator ST79 13.7.2 and 13.7.3; TIR31 section 6.1
Small pouches and mixed packs The same device used consistently, not a new assembly each day Biological indicator plus a chemical indicator ST79 13.7.3.1; TIR31
Hollow and lumened instruments A challenge that reproduces the lumen, which a flat pack does not; where the instrument or sterilizer instructions specify a hollow-load device, that device replaces the representative tray Biological indicator, with a chemical indicator if the device provides for one ST79 8.3 on lumen processing; manufacturer instructions
Loads containing implants Biological indicator in a device, in every such load Biological indicator, with a Type 5 integrating indicator where used RCDSO standard of practice; ST79 13.5.3.2
Gravity-displacement cycles A device tested in an empty chamber rather than in the load Biological indicator ST79 13.7.4
Immediate-use cycles A device for the qualification and monitoring of that cycle type Biological indicator ST79 13.8.4
Air removal check on a vacuum unit A Bowie-Dick test pack, which is a Type 2 indicator and not a spore test Chemical indicator sheet complying with ISO 11140-5 ST79 13.7.6; RCDSO monitoring flowchart

For a commercial device, ST79 supplies the questions that make a supplier conversation useful: whether the device suits the specific cycle being used, whether its performance has been shown equivalent to the user-assembled challenge, which indicators it contains, whether it is intended for routine monitoring, qualification testing or load release only, what procedure follows a questionable result, and what its shelf life and storage requirements are. A device that cannot answer the fourth question is being sold for a narrower purpose than the buyer assumes.

Where does the device go in a full load?

Routine biological monitoring is conducted in a fully loaded chamber. The device is placed on its edge if it is a small pack, or flat if it is a tray or a large pack, and it is positioned in the area of the chamber and load least favourable to sterilization — the cold point, which varies with sterilizer design but is normally the centre of the load toward the front of the chamber (ST79 13.7.3.2). The same clause applies to compact sterilizers of 2 cubic feet or less, which is the configuration most dental offices run.

Two habits break that instruction without anyone noticing. The first is placing the device at the back of the shelf because it is out of the way; the cold point is usually forward, not rearward. The second is placing it on the chamber floor, which is a surface, not a load position, and which removes the device from the load it is supposed to represent. A device that sits in an easy position produces the same result as a device that is not there.

The load state, not the device, is what changes between routine monitoring and the tests below. That is the single most useful way to remember the placement rules: the device does not move to a new place because the test changed, it moves because the chamber is empty.

How does placement change for qualification and for immediate-use cycles?

Qualification testing is the sequence that follows installation, relocation, malfunction, major repair, a process failure or a change to utilities. For sterilizers larger than 2 cubic feet, the device is placed flat — layers horizontal if the standard sixteen-towel pack is used — on a rack or shelf in an otherwise empty chamber, in the area least favourable to sterilization, normally the front, bottom section near the drain, and three consecutive cycles are run (ST79 13.8.2). For compact sterilizers, the qualification run uses a fully loaded chamber instead, with the device on edge or flat according to its form (ST79 13.8.3). For immediate-use cycles, the device goes on the bottom shelf of an otherwise empty chamber, again at the front bottom near the drain (ST79 13.8.4).

Situation Chamber state Device orientation Position Number of cycles
Routine biological monitoring, unit larger than 2 cubic feet Fully loaded On edge as a pack, flat as a tray Centre of the load toward the front, the cold point Each day of use and each cycle type
Routine biological monitoring, compact unit Fully loaded On edge if a small pack, flat if a tray Centre of the load toward the front Each day of use and each cycle type
Gravity-displacement cycle test Empty Flat Bottom shelf, front and bottom near the drain Each test
Qualification after installation, relocation or major repair, unit larger than 2 cubic feet Empty Flat, layers horizontal Rack or shelf, front and bottom near the drain Three consecutive cycles, plus three Bowie-Dick tests on vacuum units
Qualification, compact unit Fully loaded On edge or flat according to form Centre of the load toward the front Three consecutive cycles, plus three Bowie-Dick tests on vacuum units
Immediate-use cycle test Empty Flat Bottom shelf, front and bottom near the drain Each test
Bowie-Dick air removal test Empty and preheated Horizontal On a cart or shelf over the drain, not on the chamber floor Start of each day on a dynamic-air-removal unit

Where does the Bowie-Dick pack belong, and why is it different?

The Bowie-Dick test measures air removal, so it is run in the emptiest possible chamber: the pack is placed horizontally on a cart or shelf over the drain, not on the chamber floor, in an otherwise empty chamber that has been preheated, with an exposure of 3.5 to 4 minutes at 134 °C and no longer, because a longer exposure invalidates the test (ST79 13.7.6.3 and 13.7.6.4). Ontario's monitoring flowchart places it first in the day, before the first reprocessing cycle, on pre-vacuum units.

CliniEco Bowie-Dick test pack, ISO 11140-5 Type 2, 6-pack, with accept and reject reference for a daily vacuum check
A Bowie-Dick pack answers one question: was air removed from the chamber and prevented from re-entering. It is not a lethality test, which is why a passing sheet and a passing spore test are both kept.

Placement is where the two tests part company in practice. A Bowie-Dick pack belongs over the drain in an empty chamber because that is where residual air collects. A biological challenge belongs in the load, because its job is to represent the items being sterilized. Putting the spore test where the Bowie-Dick pack goes, or the reverse, produces results that look orderly and mean less than they appear to.

What is the difference between monitoring each load and monitoring each day?

Every load gets physical monitoring and a chemical indicator. That is the floor, and it does not depend on jurisdiction. What differs is the biological test, and the difference is the part most often blurred in an office policy.

Ontario requires a biological indicator placed in a process challenge device each day the sterilizer is used, and for each type of cycle used that day. The criteria mapped to CSA Z314:23 clause 16.5.8.1 read the same way, and add the clarification that pre-vacuum and gravity cycles are each covered (AHS review criteria, February 2025). Every load containing implantable devices carries a biological indicator regardless of the day's earlier result, and the load stays quarantined until the result is known. The weekly interval — at least weekly, preferably every day the sterilizer is in use — is the American baseline in the CDC guideline and in ST79, and it is not the Canadian reading.

Ontario's flowchart adds a composition rule that is easy to miss when buying devices in bulk. On the first reprocessing cycle of the day, the device is assembled with a biological indicator and a Type 5 or Type 6 chemical indicator. On subsequent cycles, the device carries a Type 5 or Type 6 chemical indicator only, and the load is released on that basis unless it contains implants (RCDSO monitoring flowchart). Buying only biological-indicator devices, or only chemical-indicator devices, leaves one of the two cycles without the device the flowchart expects.

The consumables follow from that split. A daily biological challenge needs a device plus a 24-hour steam biological indicator in 50-packs, while the later-cycle release device needs a Class 5 integrating indicator, 100 per pack that can sit in the same position without a spore vial inside.

Biological indicator vials in a box, the format placed inside a process challenge device for daily steam monitoring
The indicator is only part of the device. The resistance around it is what makes the result comparable from one day to the next, which is why the same assembly and the same position are used each time.

What goes into the record?

Four fields make a device result auditable, and all four are usually missing from a tick-box log: which device type was used, which position it occupied, the indicator lot, and the cycle type it monitored. Ontario's standard of practice requires the daily operation of every sterilizer to be reviewed and documented in a log book, with a biological indicator in a device for each day of use and each cycle type, and the log retained for at least ten years from the last entry (RCDSO Standard of Practice, Infection Prevention and Control).

Position is the field that pays for itself during an investigation. When a result is questionable, the first question is whether the device was where the manufacturer's instructions say the cold point is; without a recorded position, that question cannot be answered from the file, and the investigation restarts from the machine. The compliance log centre runs a field set that includes device type, position and lot, prints as a blank sheet, and needs no account, while the sterilization compliance hub collects the loading, packaging, release and records material behind these decisions.

Ordering for a clinic, a lab or a care home? Wholesale and multi-site ordering covers account setup and multi-site delivery, and the B2B wholesale collection lists the lines stocked for institutional buyers. CliniEco Medical distributes its sterilization consumables in Canada under Health Canada MDEL #35334. Have a question about your own facility? Send it in and you will get a written answer specific to your setup, with the regulation or standard it is based on cited. Ask your compliance question.

Reselling or buying for a facility? become a distributor for wholesale and multi-site ordering.

Related reading

Frequently Asked Questions

Can one process challenge device serve every sterilizer in the office?

Not as a rule. The device is meant to represent the load that is hardest to sterilize in the unit it monitors, and a challenge that fits a compact unit's chamber is not the challenge a larger chamber presents. ST79 separates the recommendations for units above and below 2 cubic feet for exactly this reason. If two sterilizers run different cycle types, each needs a device matched to its cycles.

Where is the cold point, and who decides?

The sterilizer manufacturer identifies it in the instructions, and the facility places the device there. Where the manufacturer is silent, the pattern in ST79 is the centre of the load toward the front for routine monitoring in a full chamber, and the front, bottom area near the drain for an empty chamber. The device goes where the manufacturer says, not where it is convenient.

Does the device replace the chemical indicator inside every pack?

No. The device is one package in the load. Each additional package still carries an external Type 1 indicator and an internal Type 4, Type 5 or Type 6 indicator, and the device itself carries the biological indicator and, where used, a Type 5 or Type 6 indicator. A device in the load does not remove the requirement for an indicator in each pack.

Can a chemical-indicator device be used for the daily spore test?

No. A biological test needs a biological indicator inside the device; a chemical indicator cannot report lethality. Ontario's flowchart uses a chemical-indicator-only device for later cycles in the day, where the release decision rests on the indicator and the physical parameters, and that is a different purpose from the daily biological challenge.

Do we need a Bowie-Dick test every day?

On a dynamic-air-removal sterilizer, yes — at the start of each day, in an empty preheated chamber, before the first reprocessing cycle. On a gravity-displacement sterilizer the test does not apply, because it measures air removal by vacuum, which that cycle does not perform. Running a Bowie-Dick pack in a gravity cycle consumes a pack and answers a question the cycle never asked.

Is a device required in every load?

Every load requires physical monitoring and a chemical indicator. A biological indicator in a device is required each day of use and for each cycle type, and in every load containing implants. For routine non-implant loads, a device may also be used to justify release where the load is not quarantined, but that is a release choice rather than a monitoring frequency.

Does the position change when the chamber is empty?

Yes, and that is the single rule that explains most of the table. In a full load the device goes into the load at the cold point; in an empty chamber, whether for a gravity-cycle test, qualification testing or an immediate-use cycle, it goes on the bottom shelf at the front, near the drain. The device is the same; the position follows the load state.

Vous travaillez déjà avec des cliniques ? Devenez représentant régional.