The failure arrives quietly. A dry-block incubator sitting on a shelf in the clinic turns a vial of Geobacillus stearothermophilus the colour that means growth, and a practice that has run three clean years of spore tests now has to answer a question it has never rehearsed: which instruments in which birth bags, used on which clients, came out of a sterilizer that was not sterilizing.
Midwifery practices are unusually exposed to that question because their buffer stock is small. A dental office with forty cassettes can pull the affected loads, substitute from stock and keep working. A practice with three birth bags cannot. Two of the three bags may be in clients' homes, and the instruments in them may already have been used at a birth last week. The response therefore has to be procedural rather than improvised, and it has to start before the incubator is opened.
The professional frame is not vague about where the responsibility sits. The College of Midwives of Ontario's Professional Standards for Midwives, in force since 1 June 2018, require every midwife to practise in accordance with the standards, and the practice owner standards require the owner to maintain a practice environment that supports compliance and to keep essential supplies available. A failed spore test is a supplies-and-systems event with clinical consequences, and it belongs to the practice rather than to the individual midwife who happened to run the cycle.
The equipment side of the response is ordinary consumable management: 24-hour readout biological indicators supplied 50 to a pack, so a failed vial never delays a retest while a replacement order is raised, and a dry-block incubator holding 24 vials per run at 56 to 60 degrees, so a control vial from the same lot can be incubated alongside the test vial every time.
What is the first thing to do when the result is positive?
Stop releasing loads. The sterilizer comes out of service, and nothing leaves it for use until the investigation closes. This is the step practices skip under pressure, because a birth is coming and the bag needs to be packed. The alternative to a sterilizer is not to use an unmonitored cycle; it is to use sterile single-use instruments from a reserve, which is why a practice that keeps a small single-use reserve for exactly this event can absorb a week of downtime without a clinical compromise.
The second action is quarantine, and it reaches further back than most people expect. Every load processed since the last negative biological indicator of the same type is treated as non-sterile, because the standard's logic is that the last good result establishes the last defensible release point. If the sterilizer runs daily and the indicators are read daily, that window is one day. If a practice runs the sterilizer twice a week and incubates in batches, the window can be a week or more, which is one more argument for reading each indicator as soon as its incubation period completes.


Which loads have to be held?
The practical way to answer that in a small practice is to work backwards from the log rather than from memory. The sterilization log required by the provincial checklist carries the load number, date, contents and person responsible precisely so that this question has an answer that does not depend on anybody's recollection.
| Step | What it means concretely | Who acts | Record produced |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hold the sterilizer | Tag it out of service; no cycle is released | Whoever reads the result | Entry in the log with the date and the result |
| Identify the window | All loads since the last negative indicator of the same cycle type | Practice lead | List of load numbers with contents |
| Quarantine stock | Any unopened pack from those loads is segregated and labelled non-sterile | Clinic staff | Quarantine location and count |
| Trace used packs | Which load went into which birth bag and, if possible, which client | Practice lead with the midwives | Traceability note linking load number to bag or client |
| Decide on notification | Whether any device was used on a client, and what that client is told | Practice lead with clinical judgement | Decision and rationale, kept with the incident file |
| Investigate and retest | Cause analysis, corrective action, repeat monitoring | Practice lead with the service provider | Investigation record and the retest results |
| Release | Return to service only after documented negative results | Practice lead | Release entry naming the date and the evidence |
Two of those rows are judgement calls rather than mechanical steps, and both are worth writing into the policy in advance. The first is whether a pack that was used on a client becomes a notification event. If the instrument was an episiotomy scissors used on intact tissue and the pack came from an unmonitored cycle, there is a real, if small, transmission risk that a clinician has to weigh. Deciding that in advance, with a named person who makes the call, is far better than deciding it at eight in the evening with a newborn in the room.
The second is the traceability link between a load and a bag. Practices that write the load number on the outside of the pack, and record which packs went into which birth bag, can answer the question in minutes. Practices that write nothing can only identify loads, not clients. This is the least expensive improvement available to a midwifery practice, and it costs a marker.
What usually caused it?
Most failures in small-practice sterilizers fall into five branches, and each branch has a different test. Working through them in order avoids the two most expensive mistakes: calling the service engineer before checking the obvious, and re-running the same cycle three times hoping for a different result.
| Branch | What to check | How to test it | What changes if it is the cause |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cycle parameters | Printout or recorded temperature, pressure and time against the cycle specification | Read the record from the failed load, not from a later one | Nothing in the machine; the release decision is about the load |
| Air removal, pre-vacuum units | Bowie-Dick or air removal test on an empty chamber | Run the test before any further loads | Repeat air removal testing and review the door seal and pump |
| Loading and packaging | Overloaded chamber, packs too tight, pouches facing the wrong way, trays stacked | Re-run with a process challenge device in a realistic load | Loading diagram in the procedure; retraining |
| Steam quality and utilities | Water supply, filters, visible condensate, recent plumbing work | Service inspection; compare against the utility requirements in the standard | Water treatment or filter change, then requalification |
| Indicator handling and incubator | Expired vials, vials stored too warm, incubator temperature drift, crushed vial | Read the incubator temperature record and check the lot | Incubator service and a temperature verification record |
The fifth branch is the one that produces false positives, and it is worth taking seriously before a machine is condemned. An incubator that has drifted below its specified band, a vial that was stored on a windowsill, or a lot past its expiry will all turn a positive that says nothing about the sterilizer. That is why the daily routine includes a control vial from the same lot, and why the incubator itself needs a temperature record rather than a sticker.
How does the sterilizer come back into service?
By documented results rather than by wishfulness. The standard's qualification logic, and the routine monitoring requirement that a biological indicator in a process challenge device be run each day the sterilizer is used and for each cycle type used that day, together produce a workable rule: repeat monitoring with controls until consecutive negative results are obtained, and where the failure followed a repair, a relocation or a change in the water or steam supply, run the qualification again rather than assuming the repair restored the machine to its qualified state.
For a steam sterilizer the practical sequence is an empty-chamber run with a process challenge device in place, repeated so that the practice has consecutive negatives rather than a single pass, plus air removal testing on dynamic air removal units. The practice then writes the number of consecutive negatives it required into its procedure, because that number is what the next person will need when a different sterilizer fails in two years' time.
The record of the event is as important as the record of the recovery. A file that contains the failed result, the affected loads, the quarantine list, the investigation, the corrective action taken and the retest results is the difference between a managed incident and an unexplained gap in the log. It should live with the sterilization records, not in a separate folder nobody opens.
What does all of this have to look like in the log?
The Public Health Ontario checklist requires the sterilization log to show the load control label with sterilizer number, load number and date, the chart or printout of physical parameters, the load contents, the person responsible, the chemical indicator results and the biological indicator results. A failure event adds four more things that belong on the same page or attached to it: the date the result was read, the loads held, the action taken and the release date.
In a practice that runs one small sterilizer, the tidy version is a single log with a notes column wide enough to write "BI positive, sterilizer held, loads 41 to 43 quarantined, retest 14 and 15 negative, released 12 March". That single line answers an inspector's question, a client's question and, if it ever comes to it, a lawyer's question, without anybody reconstructing the week from memory.
None of this requires software. It requires a log that exists, a marker for the pack, and a written procedure that says who does what when the vial turns. A printable compliance log sheet covers the bench record; the procedure and the incident file are the practice owner's job, and they are the part that survives staff turnover.
Where does a clinic take this next?
Four things a clinic can act on rather than read: a printable compliance log sheet that records receiving dates, lot numbers and open-on dates and exports from the browser; the clinic supply planner that turns daily bench counts into cases per month; and, where a finding has to be documented for an inspector, Ask your compliance question which returns a written answer citing the regulation or standard it rests on.
Facility and multi-site buyers can also ask about wholesale and multi-site ordering for case pricing and account setup. Reselling? become a distributor.
Related reading
- Biological indicator incubator temperature verification and documentation
- Dry-bath incubator temperature stability for biological indicators
- How a midwifery clinic segregates biomedical waste in Canada
- How many biological indicators a sterilizer needs each week
Frequently Asked Questions
Does one positive biological indicator mean every load that week is non-sterile?
Every load processed since the last negative indicator of the same cycle type is treated as non-sterile until the investigation says otherwise. That is usually a shorter window than a week, because a practice running routine monitoring reads an indicator each day the sterilizer is used. The window is defined by the last negative result, not by the calendar, so the log is what fixes its length.
Can the practice keep using the sterilizer while it retests?
Not for client care. The sterilizer is held while the investigation runs, and the practice works from single-use reserves or from stock sterilized before the last negative indicator. Running production loads between retests contaminates the evidence: if a later retest passes, the practice cannot show which loads were processed in the interval, and if it fails, the window widens again.
What if the positive turns out to be a false positive?
Then the investigation record says so, with the evidence: a control vial that also grew, an incubator outside its temperature band, an expired lot, or a vial that was crushed in handling. The loads can be released, but the release has to be documented with the reason. A false positive that is handled by quietly throwing the vial away leaves a gap in the log that looks identical to a real failure that was covered up.
Do single-use instruments need any of this?
No, and that is the point of them. A device supplied sterile and discarded after use has no load, no indicator and no quarantine. The exposure is the reserve itself: if the practice relies on single-use instruments during a sterilizer outage, the reserve has to exist before the outage and has to be checked for expiry. The practice owner standard about essential supplies being available is the obligation that makes the reserve a requirement rather than a good intention.
How often should the incubator be checked?
The incubator has to hold its specified temperature band, and the practice needs a record that shows it did. A daily reading at the start of incubation plus a periodic verification against a reference thermometer is the ordinary arrangement for a small practice; the incubator's own display is not a verification. Indicators that are incubated outside the band can read negative when they should read positive, which is the failure mode nobody catches without a temperature record.
Who decides whether a client has to be told?
The practice lead, in consultation with the clinicians involved, using the traceability record to establish whether any device from the affected loads was used on a client. The decision, and the reasoning behind it, is documented in the incident file. Deciding in advance who holds that authority, and on what criteria, is what keeps the conversation clinical instead of improvised.
Sources
CSA Group. CAN/CSA-Z314:23, Canadian medical device reprocessing, routine monitoring of steam sterilization, biological indicators in process challenge devices, and qualification requirements.
Public Health Ontario. IPAC Checklist for Clinical Office Practice: Reprocessing of Medical Equipment/Devices, 2nd revision, July 2019, record keeping item 1.1.
College of Midwives of Ontario. Professional Standards for Midwives, approved 21 March 2018, implemented 1 June 2018, including practice owner standards 10 to 12.
College of Midwives of Ontario. Practice advisory: communicable illness and transmission prevention.
Ontario Midwives. Midwifery equipment disinfecting guidance, 2019.
CliniEco Medical distributes clinic and laboratory consumables in Canada under MDEL #35334. Requirements that bind a specific practice remain the ones in its own provincial guidance, manufacturer instructions and written procedures.
Last updated: 17 November 2026.