What Must a Dermatology Clinic Do When a Biological Indicator Fails?

Three self-contained biological indicator vials with bilingual labels, used to confirm steam sterilization in a clinic sterilizer

A positive biological indicator is not a paperwork event. It means the last load out of that sterilizer may not be sterile, and in a dermatology clinic the instruments in that load were used on skin that had just been opened, biopsied or curetted. The sequence that follows is short, and it is almost always run under time pressure.

This page sets out what the test result actually proves, the order the Canadian provincial guidance puts the response in, which loads have to be held back, how a repeat test changes the decision, and where the Canadian and American positions genuinely part company. The consumables that make the response fast are the 24-hour self-contained biological indicator, the dry-block incubator that reads it in house, and the Class 5 steam chemical integrator that goes inside the process challenge device.

Quick facts on a failed biological indicator in a dermatology clinic

  • The sterilizer comes out of service before anything else happens, and the repeat test is run while it stays out.
  • The review covers every load since the last negative biological indicator, not only the load that produced the failure.
  • The repeat test uses the same cycle that produced the failure, not a different one.
  • Overloading, inadequate package separation and incorrect or excessive packaging are named as common causes when there is no mechanical failure.
  • A second positive result moves the case from a laboratory event to a sterilizer investigation with the manufacturer.
  • The record of the investigation is what an inspector reads six months later, not the vial.

What does a positive biological indicator actually prove?

A biological indicator carries a defined population of spores with a known resistance to the process it is testing. For steam, that organism is Geobacillus stearothermophilus; for dry heat and ethylene oxide it is Bacillus atrophaeus. The vial is placed inside a process challenge device so that the spores sit behind the same barrier the packaged instruments present, and it is incubated afterwards. Growth means the process did not deliver the lethality it was supposed to deliver to that challenge.

Three monitors answer three different questions, and the difference matters at the moment of a failure. The Ontario reprocessing standard sets them out in a way that is worth keeping on the wall: the physical monitor records time, temperature and pressure for the cycle; the chemical indicator shows exposure to the process variables; the biological indicator is the only one that measures lethality directly. That is why a colour change on the pouch cannot clear a positive spore test, and why a clean printout cannot either.

Monitor What it reads What it cannot tell you
Physical (printout, data logger) Time, temperature and pressure achieved in the chamber Whether steam penetrated the pack or the load
Chemical indicator, external (Class 1) That the package saw the process Whether the conditions were sufficient for sterility
Chemical indicator, internal (Class 4 to 6) Penetration at a defined point inside the pack Direct lethality against a resistant organism
Biological indicator (Class 1 per ISO 11138-1) Whether the process killed a known resistant spore population Which load, which pack, or which parameter failed

The spore test is a sample, not a survey. A single positive result says the process failed at least once in the challenge device that was tested; it does not say which of the loads in the window were affected, which is precisely why the response works backwards through the record rather than forwards from the vial.

What is the order of steps after a failed spore test?

The order is not arbitrary. Each step protects the next one, and the two that get skipped in a busy skin clinic are the second and the fifth.

Step Action What it protects
1 Take the sterilizer out of service and label it Stops a second suspect load being produced
2 Pull the physical and chemical records back to the last negative biological indicator Defines the recall window
3 Quarantine the packs from that window, used or unused Stops an affected pack reaching a procedure
4 Inspect the failed load for loading and packaging errors Separates operator error from machine failure
5 Repeat the biological indicator using the same cycle Tests the machine, not a new setting
6 Record the investigation, the decision and the release Answers the review that comes later

Ontario's guidance for clinical office practice, revised in November 2026, states the response in these terms: record all equipment and devices in each processed load so the recall can be tracked, repeat the test, and if practical do not release any items processed since the last negative test. If the repeat test is negative and there is no indication of a system malfunction, the office continues as normal. If the repeated process indicates a failure, the document has to record the time, date, load description and the results of physical, chemical and biological monitoring; the sterilizer manufacturer is contacted; after repair and maintenance the sterilizer is re-challenged with a biological indicator; the recalled items are re-sterilized once the indicators are acceptable; and the risk to patients is assessed.

The provincial reprocessing standard adds the boundary that office guidance compresses: after a failed biological indicator the recall has to include the devices in the failed load and all other devices processed in that sterilizer since the last successfully sterilized load. In a clinic that tests once a day, that window is a day. In a clinic that tests once a week, the same failure reaches back five working days of punch biopsies, curettes and suture sets.

Which loads have to be held, and what does held mean?

Sort the window into three groups, because the response is different for each and the sorting is what the record has to show.

Group What it is in a dermatology clinic Response
Sealed packs still on the shelf Curettes, tissue forceps, scissors, needle holders in pouches Quarantine; reprocess before use. Nothing has been exposed
Instruments used since the last negative test Excision and biopsy sets already opened Clinician and medical director informed; risk assessment recorded
Items held for a booked procedure Sets staged for the next list Remain quarantined until the repeat result is known

Implantable devices are the model the standards use for the third group: a biological indicator goes into every load containing implants and those devices stay quarantined until the result is known. Most dermatology clinics place no implants, but the same discipline applies to anything staged for a procedure on the day the result lands, because the alternative is a decision made by whoever is holding the phone.

Where quarantine is not practical, the provincial standard allows a documented alternative for routine loads: evaluation of a Class 5 or Class 6 chemical indicator together with the specific cycle physical parameters can justify release. That route is a justification written into the record, not a shortcut around the spore test, and it does not extend to implantable devices.

What changes if the repeat test is also positive?

The case changes owner. A single positive with a clean repeat points at the load, the packaging or the operator; two positives point at the sterilizer. At that stage the manufacturer is contacted, the unit is serviced, and the re-challenge happens after the repair rather than instead of it. Items from the recall window are re-sterilized only once the indicators are acceptable, and the patient risk assessment becomes a clinical decision rather than a documentation exercise.

Requalification is the formal name for getting back to routine service, and the provincial standard lists the events that trigger it rather than a calendar: after major repairs, after construction, relocation or other environmental changes in the area, after unexplained sterility failures, after changes in steam supply or delivery, and after repairs to the emission control system. A second positive result falls squarely inside the second of those categories.

How do Canada and the United States differ on biological indicator frequency?

This is the difference that catches clinics that operate on both sides of the border, and it is a difference in the minimum, not in the science.

Item Canada (Ontario guidance) United States (CDC guidance)
Biological indicator frequency, steam Once each day the sterilizer is used, and with each type of cycle used that day At least weekly; daily is described as allowing earlier detection on a sterilizer used several times a day
Air removal test, dynamic air removal sterilizer Every day the sterilizer is used, with a Class 2 indicator Recommended for each sterilizer each day it is used, per the same monitoring logic
Implant loads Biological indicator in every load; quarantine until the result is known Biological indicator in every load containing implants; hold implants until the result is known
Release without a spore result Class 5 or 6 chemical indicator plus cycle physical parameters may justify release of routine loads Left to facility policy and accreditation standards

The practical consequence is inventory, not philosophy. A clinic that moves from a weekly routine to a daily one needs roughly five times the indicator volume for the same number of sterilizer days, plus incubation capacity if the results are read in house. A 24-hour self-contained indicator read in a dry-block incubator fits that rhythm; a mail-out service does not.

Do Canada and the United States differ on recalling loads after one positive?

They do, and this is the larger of the two differences. Canadian provincial guidance treats a positive biological indicator as a recall trigger that runs back to the last successfully sterilized load. The CDC guidance on sterilizing practices takes a narrower position for steam: after a single positive spore test, objects other than implantable objects do not need to be recalled because of that single result unless the sterilizer or the procedure is defective or the cycle settings were inappropriate, and if additional spore tests remain positive the items are considered non-sterile and recalled and reprocessed.

Question Canada (Ontario provincial guidance) United States (CDC)
Single positive, steam, no implant Recall window runs back to the last negative biological indicator No recall required on the single result alone if the unit and procedure are sound
Repeat positives Full investigation, repair, re-challenge and re-sterilization of the recalled items Items considered non-sterile; recall and reprocess
Non-steam processes Same recall logic Conservative approach applied: treat everything back to the last negative as non-sterile
Who the record protects The inspector and the patient notification trail The accreditation survey and the facility policy

A clinic working to the Canadian standard and audited against the American one will look over-documented, which is the safe direction. A clinic working to the American minimum and inspected in Ontario will be missing both the daily results and the recall window.

Which records does the investigation have to leave behind?

Five artefacts, and the first four are the ones an inspector asks for. The load record for each cycle, signed by the person who ran it, showing time, temperature, pressure and the cycle used. The biological indicator result with the lot number, the control result and the incubation start and finish. The chemical indicator result at package level, which is what ties a specific pack to the failed load. The maintenance and repair record, which is what converts a two-week failure into a documented repair. And the investigation note itself, which states what was quarantined, what was released, who was told and why.

Retention is set by more than one instrument. Under Ontario's regulation for physicians, the clinical record is retained at least ten years after the last entry, or until ten years after the day the patient reached or would have reached eighteen years of age, whichever comes first. The reprocessing standard asks for records to be kept according to facility policy, which is the point at which a clinic writes its own rule and then has to live with it. A ten-year floor in the policy costs nothing and matches the clinical record beside it.

Which consumables make the response fast?

Three lines, each answering a different part of the sequence. The indicator itself has to match the cycle and the sterilizer type, which is what the ISO 11138 series covers: Part 1 for general requirements, Part 3 for moist heat. The incubator decides whether the answer arrives this afternoon or next week. And the integrator inside the process challenge device is what allows a documented release decision when quarantine is not practical.

Where packs are prepared in the treatment room rather than a dedicated reprocessing area, the packaging matters as well: a self-sealing pouch with an external indicator and a writable panel saves the step where someone writes through the film and punctures it next to the instrument. Where a load is released on a biological result, the shelf carries the Class 4 self-sealing sterilization pouch and the indicator stock beside it.

Three self-contained biological indicator vials with bilingual labels, used to confirm steam sterilization in a clinic sterilizer

The log for the investigation is in the compliance log centre, which also carries the sterilization log generator for the wall of the reprocessing room. The two documents answer different questions: the cycle log answers what the sterilizer did, and the investigation sheet answers what the clinic did about it.

A dry-block incubator with numbered wells holding biological indicator vials, used to read daily spore tests in a clinic

Rebuilding a monitoring routine after a failure? Send the sterilizer model, the cycles run in a week and the number of loads per day, and the answer will name the indicator volume and the incubation capacity the routine needs. Ask a Compliance Specialist.

Ordering for several clinics or a group of practices? The institutional account enquiry page covers case quantities and account setup. Reselling? become a distributor.

Related reading

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a positive biological indicator always mean the load was not sterile?

It means the process failed the challenge device that was tested, so the load cannot be assumed sterile. The documented response is to hold or recall the loads processed since the last negative result, repeat the test on the same cycle, and release only when the indicators support it.

Can a Class 5 integrator be used instead of a spore test?

No. An integrator can justify the release of a routine load when quarantine for a biological result is not practical, and it is read alongside the cycle physical parameters. It does not replace the biological indicator, which is the only monitor that measures lethality against a resistant organism.

How long does the sterilizer stay out of service?

Until the repeat result is known and, if the repeat is also positive, until the unit has been serviced and re-challenged with a biological indicator. The provincial standard is explicit that the unit is not approved for use while a biological test is positive.

What if the failed test came from a load of single-use biopsy punches?

Disposable punches are not reprocessed, so the exposure question moves to the reusable instruments in the same load and to the loads before it. The recall window is defined by the record, not by the item type.

Do we need to tell patients?

The provincial guidance requires a procedure for notification of physicians, patients, other facilities and regulatory bodies if indicated, and a risk assessment to decide whether it is indicated. Writing the decision down, including a decision not to notify, is part of the record.

Where do the indicator lot numbers go?

In the cycle record next to the result, together with the control vial result and the incubation times. Without the lot number, a cluster of failures across weeks cannot be separated from a single bad batch of indicators.

Standards, guidance and regulations are cited as published at the time of writing and are not reproduced in full. Guidance is revised, so confirm the version in force for your province and the instructions for use of the equipment you operate. This article is for information and is not legal advice. CliniEco Medical distributes medical consumables under MDEL #35334.

Sources and version notes

Vous travaillez déjà avec des cliniques ? Devenez représentant régional.