Installation, operational and performance qualification are three separate evidence packages, and each answers a different question: whether the sterilizer was built and connected as specified, whether it controls the cycle across its stated range, and whether the loads a clinic actually runs come out sterile. The part most Canadian clinic files are missing is not the test itself but the signature line that says who performed it, who reviewed it, and what evidence the reviewer was looking at. This guide sets out, stage by stage, who does the work, who signs, what document results, and which events force the whole thing to be repeated.
The spore-test leg of performance qualification depends on a biological indicator that matches the cycle and the record trail around it, which is why clinics standardise on one format such as this
24-hour self-contained biological indicator — 25-pack with Geobacillus stearothermophilus and a lot number that can be traced into the load record.
What does each of the three qualifications actually prove?
The three stages are not three levels of the same test. They answer three different questions, produce three different documents, and are usually performed by three different parties.
| Stage | Question it answers | What is measured | Document produced | Who holds the raw data |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Installation qualification (IQ) | Was the unit built, delivered, sited and connected as specified? | Utilities (steam supply, water, drain, electrical), chamber and door condition, control software version, sensor calibration status, clearances and room conditions | Installation checklist, utility readings, calibration certificates, as-built record | Installing contractor or manufacturer field service; copy to the clinic |
| Operational qualification (OQ) | Does the unit control the cycle across its stated operating range? | Vacuum leak rate, air removal, temperature distribution across the chamber, pressure and temperature control at set points, alarm and interlock function, cycle timing | Test protocol with raw readings and pass/fail against acceptance criteria | Test provider; the clinic should hold the raw readings, not only the summary |
| Performance qualification (PQ) | Do the loads this clinic actually runs come out sterile under the routine cycle? | Biological indicator in a process challenge device, chemical indicators, load configuration, and the specific load types in use | Completed PQ record with indicator lot numbers, incubation records and results | The clinic, because the results come from its own routine monitoring |
Two boundaries are worth stating plainly. IQ does not test sterilization performance, and PQ is not a factory acceptance test: it is the clinic's own evidence that its loads, its packaging and its cycle work together. A file that contains an impressive IQ and OQ but a single PQ run at installation has not qualified the loads the clinic runs today.

Who performs and who signs each stage?
No single federal statute in Canada prescribes who must carry out IQ, OQ and PQ. What the standards and provincial guidance require is that responsibilities be defined and that the record shows who did what. The PIDAC provincial guidance for Ontario asks that reprocessing policies include "clearly defined responsibilities", and it expects that input from a professional with infection prevention and control expertise be obtained before a new sterilizer is purchased. It also requires that staff involved in reprocessing have completed a recognised qualification or certification course, with re-certification strongly recommended at least every five years. That last point matters more than it looks: a signature line is only meaningful if the person behind it is trained for the task.
| Stage | Typical performer in Canada | Who signs | What the signature represents | What stays with the clinic |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| IQ | Manufacturer field service engineer or the installing contractor | Installer, plus the clinic manager accepting the installation | Installed as specified, with utilities verified | As-built record, utility readings, calibration certificates |
| OQ | Service engineer, or an independent test provider engaged by the clinic | Tester, countersigned by the clinic's designated reprocessing lead | The unit met its stated limits on the test day | Raw readings and acceptance criteria, not just a pass letter |
| PQ | The clinic itself, using the provider's protocol and its own indicators | The person who read the result, plus the person who released the loads | Load types in the file are released on evidence | Indicator lot traceability, incubator records, load configuration |
In a two-chair practice the same person often performs, reads and files everything. That is a staffing fact, not a documentation exemption: the file should still show, per cycle, who read which result and when. Where a clinic has only one trained reprocessing staff member, the countersignature is usually the practice principal or the office manager, and its purpose is to show that a second person saw the evidence. Where a repair forces a same-day requalification, the indicator format decides whether release can happen that day: a 3-hour rapid-readout fluorescence biological indicator — 50-pack is read in the same shift, while a 24-hour format pushes the decision to the next working day.

What has to be on file before the first patient load?
The provincial guidance is unusually specific at this point, and it is specific in a way that maps neatly onto the three stages. Following installation of a new sterilizer, the unit must pass at least three consecutive cycles with the appropriate challenges (biological and chemical) placed in an empty sterilizer, and at least one cycle challenged with a full test load, before it can be put into routine service — that is the operational and performance evidence, in one sentence. For dynamic air removal (vacuum) units, three consecutive air removal tests must be conducted in an empty sterilizer with an air detection test pack such as a Bowie-Dick pack, and the guidance states plainly that a sterilizer shall not be approved for use if the biological indicator yields a positive result on any of the tests.
The clause reference attached to that air removal requirement is worth flagging for anyone copying it into a policy today. The 2013 provincial guidance points to CSA Z314.3-09, clauses 12.4.3.2 to 12.4.3.4. CSA Group now lists Z314.3-09 (R2014) as withdrawn, and Z314.3-14 as withdrawn as well; the current consolidated volume is CSA Z314:23. Copying a withdrawn clause number into a clinic policy is a small thing that reads badly in an audit.
So the pre-first-load file should contain, at minimum:
- The installation record and utility readings at commissioning (IQ).
- Calibration certificates for the chamber sensors, with dates and traceability.
- The OQ protocol with raw readings and the acceptance criteria applied.
- Three consecutive challenged cycles plus one full-load cycle (PQ), each with indicator lot numbers.
- Three consecutive air removal tests for vacuum units, dated and signed.
- The manufacturer's written installation and use instructions, kept with the file.
- A signature page naming who performed, who reviewed and who accepted.
- The load configuration used for PQ, documented well enough that a new employee can reproduce the same wraps, pouches and instrument sets.
Which events force a repeat, and which do not?
Requalification is triggered by change, and the trigger list is short enough to memorise. The provincial guidance requires that sterilizers be monitored with a test load and fully re-qualified after major repairs to an existing sterilizer; when there has been construction, relocation or other environmental changes in the area; after unexplained sterility failures; after changes in the steam and/or ethylene oxide supply or delivery; and after repairs or modification to the emission control system. Note the phrase "monitored with a test load" — requalification is not a spore test on an empty chamber.
| Event | Repeat required? | Stage re-entered | Evidence to file |
|---|---|---|---|
| Major repair (chamber, door, vacuum system, control board) | Yes | OQ, then PQ | Repair report, OQ readings, challenged cycles |
| Relocation, renovation, or change to the room's air handling | Yes | IQ (site), then OQ and PQ | New utility readings, OQ protocol, PQ record |
| Unexplained sterility failure or positive indicator | Yes | Investigation, then PQ | Failure report, corrective action, requalification record |
| Change in steam supply, boiler, or delivery conditions | Yes | OQ, then PQ | Steam quality and pressure readings before and after |
| Repair or modification to the emission control system | Yes | OQ, then PQ | Service record, test readings |
| New instrument set that changes load density or configuration | Depends | PQ on that load type | PQ record for the new configuration |
| Switching pouch or roll brand or size | No, but packaging validation applies | Packaging process validation, not sterilizer PQ | Seal validation record under the packaging standard |
| Routine preventive maintenance on the manufacturer's schedule | Not in itself | None beyond routine monitoring | Maintenance log entry |
The pouch line in that table catches clinics out in both directions. A new pouch brand does not require you to requalify the sterilizer, because the sterilizer's performance on a given load type is unchanged; it does require that the sealing process itself be validated, which is a different question with a different record, governed by the packaging standards rather than the sterilizer standards. The reverse mistake also happens: a clinic changes its wrapping method for the same instruments and assumes nothing needs redoing, when load configuration is exactly the variable PQ is meant to control.
Where do small clinics usually get caught?
| Gap | How it shows up later | What closes it |
|---|---|---|
| Delivery slip filed instead of an installation record | Utilities and calibration cannot be shown at the time of installation | Reconstruct the IQ from service records, then re-baseline |
| OQ summary letter with no raw readings | Cannot show the acceptance criteria were met | Request the test data, not the cover letter |
| PQ run once at installation and never after a repair | Requalification obligation unmet on a documented trigger | Trigger table posted next to the unit |
| Air removal tests done but not as three consecutive runs | Method does not match the documented requirement | Redo the series, date and sign each run |
| Indicator lots and incubation records kept apart from the load record | Traceability breaks at exactly the point an investigator asks about | One load record that carries the lot number |
| Undated or unreadable signatures | Record cannot show who accepted what | Signature block with name, role and date |
| Records retention not defined | Log and validation records disappear before their time | Retention rule written into the policy |
Retention is the one gap with a clear provincial anchor in dentistry: the daily operation of every sterilizer must be reviewed and documented in a log book, and that log book must be maintained for at least 10 years from the date of the last entry. Validation and requalification records sit in the same evidence chain as that log, so treating them as one file is both simpler and more defensible than keeping two.
How do the standards and the regulators fit together?
Three layers are doing different work. ISO 17665:2024 provides the requirements for the development, validation and routine control of moist heat sterilization processes for medical devices, and its scope explicitly considers application within both industrial and health care settings — it is the frame the evidence has to satisfy. ISO 11138-3:2017 specifies requirements for the test organisms, inoculated carriers, biological indicators and test methods used to assess moist heat processes, and notes that validation and process control requirements sit in the ISO 17665 series; ISO 11140-4:2007 specifies the Class 2 indicator used as an alternative to the Bowie-Dick test, which is what a clinic is relying on when it documents air removal with an indicator rather than a test pack. AAMI ST79:2017, reaffirmed in 2022 with its 2020 amendments, remains the North American reference text that most hospital and clinic policies are written against, and CSA Z314:23 is the current consolidated Canadian volume now that the separate Z314.3 documents are withdrawn — the volume that supersedes the clause numbering still quoted in older provincial guidance. On the regulatory side, provincial guidance such as the Ontario PIDAC document and the RCDSO standard of practice set what a practice must be able to show, which is why the signature and retention questions are regulator questions rather than standards questions.
For the day-to-day monitoring that follows qualification, and for the paperwork that a clinic will actually be asked to produce, the practical entries are the sterilization compliance hub, the compliance log centre, and — where a file is being rebuilt after a gap — a compliance review conversation rather than another template. Clinics buying for more than one site, or for a group of practices, tend to start from the wholesale and institutional supply route. Reselling? become a distributor.
Related reading
- What belongs inside an IQ, OQ and PQ document set covers the contents of each document; this article covers who produces and signs them.
- Commissioning and requalification compared across Canada and the United States sets the two evidence regimes side by side.
- Validation records and Canadian retention rules answers the "how long do we keep it" question in more depth.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a Canadian clinic have to hire a third party to perform OQ?
Not necessarily, but the test has to be performed by someone competent to run it and interpret the readings, and the file has to show that. Many clinics use the sterilizer supplier's field service for IQ and OQ because the acceptance criteria come from the manufacturer's specification, then run PQ themselves because it depends on their own loads and their own indicators. What is not acceptable is an OQ record that cannot show who performed the test and against which criteria.
Who signs the PQ record if the clinic has only one trained reprocessing staff member?
The person who read the result signs for the reading, and a second person — typically the practice principal or office manager — countersigns as reviewer. The point of the second signature is not technical second-guessing; it is evidence that the result left the hands of the person who produced it and was seen by someone accountable for releasing loads.
Is an empty-chamber biological indicator test enough to requalify after a repair?
No. The provincial requirement is that sterilizers be monitored with a test load when they are requalified, which means the challenge has to sit in a load that resembles routine production, not in an empty chamber. An empty-chamber result answers a narrower question about the chamber itself.
Which standard applies to the air removal test — the provincial guidance or CSA?
Both, but they are at different ages. The provincial guidance describes the requirement and points to CSA Z314.3-09 clauses 12.4.3.2 to 12.4.3.4 for the method; CSA Group now lists Z314.3-09 (R2014) and Z314.3-14 as withdrawn, with CSA Z314:23 as the current consolidated volume. Document the requirement as written in provincial guidance, then verify the method against the current CSA volume rather than reproducing an old clause number.
Does changing our pouch supplier force us to requalify the sterilizer?
It forces packaging process validation, which is a separate exercise under the packaging standards, and it does not by itself re-open sterilizer OQ or PQ. If the change alters how loads are packed — different pouch thickness changing the load density, for example — then PQ on that load type is the right response.
How long should qualification records be kept?
Match the retention rule that already applies to your sterilizer log. In Ontario dentistry the log book must be maintained for at least 10 years from the date of the last entry, and the qualification records sit in the same evidence chain, so most practices keep installation, operational and performance records for the life of the unit plus that retention period.
What is the single most useful thing to add to a thin file?
A one-page trigger table, posted beside the sterilizer, that lists the five events which force requalification and names who to call for each. Thin files are usually thin because nobody knew that a repair or a renovation restarted the evidence clock.
Sources
- ISO 17665:2024 — Sterilization of health care products, moist heat: requirements for the development, validation and routine control of a sterilization process for medical devices
- ISO 11138-3:2017 — Biological indicators for moist heat sterilization processes
- ISO 11140-4:2007 — Class 2 indicators as an alternative to the Bowie and Dick-type test
- ANSI/AAMI ST79:2017/(R)2022 with amendments A1 to A4 — Comprehensive guide to steam sterilization and sterility assurance in health care facilities
- CSA Z314:23 — Medical device reprocessing (current consolidated volume)
- CSA Z314.3-09 (R2014) — Effective sterilization in health care facilities by the steam process (listed as withdrawn)
- CSA Z314.3-14 — Effective sterilization in health care settings by the steam process (listed as withdrawn)
- Public Health Ontario (PIDAC) — Provincial guidance on cleaning, disinfection and sterilization in all health care settings
- Public Health Ontario — Reprocessing of medical equipment and devices
- Public Health Ontario — IPAC checklist for dental reprocessing
- RCDSO — Standard of practice: infection prevention and control in the dental office, version 3
- RCDSO — Infection prevention and control guidance index
CliniEco Medical distributes sterilization monitoring consumables in Canada under Health Canada MDEL #35334.