Dermatology reprocessing looks simple because the instruments are small and the procedures are quick, and that is exactly how clinics get it wrong. The level of reprocessing is not set by the size of the instrument or by how minor the procedure feels; it is set by what the instrument touches. A comedone extractor pressed on intact skin, a curette scraped across a keratosis, and a punch driven through the dermis into sterile tissue sit at three different levels, and each level has its own minimum, its own packaging consequence and its own record.
The sequence itself is fixed: clean first, then either sterilize or apply high-level chemistry depending on contact, then package and store so the item is still in the required state when it reaches the patient. For a dermatology clinic the practical decision is therefore made at the point of purchase — heat-tolerant instruments that can be sterilized in-house, and a Class 4 self-sealing sterilization pouch, 200 per box for the packaging step that follows — rather than at the bench under time pressure.
Which dermatology instruments are critical, semicritical and noncritical?
Ontario’s college guidance adopts the Spaulding classification and applies it without a dermatology exception. Critical items enter sterile body sites, including the vascular system, and require cleaning followed by sterilization; the college’s examples include surgical instruments and biopsy instruments. Semicritical items contact non-intact skin or mucous membranes without penetrating them and require cleaning followed by high-level disinfection, with sterilization preferred. Noncritical items touch only intact skin, or do not touch the patient at all, and require cleaning followed by low-level disinfection.
The dermatology version of that table is where the arguments happen. A biopsy punch that removes a core of skin is a critical item by definition, and a disposable punch is never reprocessed. A dermal curette that scrapes a lesion until it bleeds has breached the skin, which places it with the critical instruments on the same reasoning. Scissors and forceps used to handle tissue during a shave or excision are critical. A comedone extractor used on intact skin is a different case, and so is a Wood’s lamp or a dermoscope faceplate that touches only intact skin.
| Instrument | Contact | Classification | Minimum reprocessing between patients |
|---|---|---|---|
| Biopsy punch (disposable) | Enters dermis and subcutaneous tissue | Critical, single use | Not reprocessed; discarded into a sharps container |
| Dermal curette, tissue nippers | Scrapes and cuts until bleeding | Critical | Cleaning followed by sterilization |
| Scissors, forceps, needle holder used on tissue | Contact with open tissue and blood | Critical | Cleaning followed by sterilization |
| Comedone extractor on intact skin | Intact skin only | Noncritical | Cleaning followed by low-level disinfection |
| Comedone extractor on inflamed or broken skin | Non-intact skin | Semicritical | Cleaning followed by high-level disinfection; sterilization preferred |
| Cryotherapy probe or spray nozzle | Depends on contact; manufacturer instructions decide | Usually noncritical to semicritical | Clean and disinfect per the device instructions |
| Dermoscope faceplate, Wood’s lamp handle | Intact skin | Noncritical | Cleaning followed by low-level disinfection |


What does each level actually require?
Critical items are cleaned and then sterilized, with steam as the preferred method for heat-tolerant instruments. Semicritical items are cleaned and then high-level disinfected if they cannot tolerate sterilization, and the chemistry has to be used at the concentration, temperature and contact time in the manufacturer’s instructions, checked with test strips, and not topped up with fresh solution. Noncritical items are cleaned and low-level disinfected between patients.

Cleaning is the step that decides whether any of the rest works. Residual organic material protects microorganisms and neutralises chemical disinfectants, which is why the Canadian guidance treats cleaning as a prerequisite rather than a preliminary. In a dermatology clinic that means an enzymatic or detergent wash at the concentration the maker specifies, mechanical action where the instrument has a lumen or a hinge, a rinse, and drying before packaging. An ultrasonic multi-enzyme cleaning solution, 4 litre concentrate is formulated for that step, and it does nothing for an instrument that goes into the bath without being opened at the hinge.
Which methods are not acceptable in a Canadian clinic?
The list is short and provincial guidance states it plainly: a dishwasher, regardless of whether it has a sanitizing cycle, boiling, ultraviolet irradiation, glass bead sterilizers, chemiclave sterilizers and microwave ovens are not acceptable methods of disinfection or sterilization for reusable medical equipment. Those six come up in dermatology more than in dentistry, because small metal instruments and a clinic that has owned a glass bead sterilizer since the 1990s are a common pairing.
Sterilization is also a process with a validated envelope rather than a hot box. A gravity displacement unit and a pre-vacuum unit do not sterilize the same load in the same way, and an instrument that has a lumen, a hinge or a matte surface needs the air removed before steam can reach it. That is why the college guidance prefers pre-vacuum benchtop sterilizers for clinic settings, and why the manufacturer’s instructions for the specific instrument decide whether it can be sterilized at all.
| Method | Status for reusable instruments | Why clinics reach for it, and what to do instead |
|---|---|---|
| Steam sterilization, pre-vacuum benchtop | Preferred for heat-tolerant critical and semicritical items | The clinic standards; qualify the unit and monitor each cycle |
| Steam sterilization, gravity displacement | Acceptable where the load and the manufacturer instructions support it | Hollow and wrapped loads are the constraint; check the cycle type |
| High-level chemical disinfection | For semicritical items that cannot tolerate heat, with test strips and documented contact time | Use the chemistry at the labelled concentration and temperature, and never top up a used bath |
| Dishwasher, boiling, microwave, ultraviolet cabinet | Not acceptable | Speed and convenience; none of them is a validated reprocessing method |
| Glass bead sterilizer, chemiclave | Not acceptable | Legacy equipment still in some procedure rooms; decommission it |
What about the single-use items a dermatology clinic handles?
Single-use devices are not reprocessed, and the label is the instruction. That covers biopsy punches, scalpels, suture needles, injection needles, cannulae and the disposable tips that come with some devices. The practical discipline is procurement rather than reprocessing: a clinic that buys one reusable punch to save money has created an instrument that must be sterilized after every use, tracked, and inspected for sharpness, which is a worse bargain than it looks.
Sharps also bring Ontario’s needle safety rule into the room. Where a safety-engineered needle is available for a procedure, the regulation requires its use, and a dermatology clinic doing injections, sclerotherapy or cosmetic procedures is inside that requirement. The related obligation is the written procedure for sharps injury prevention and management, which the college checklist expects to see.
What records does a dermatology clinic keep?
Three records carry the weight. The sterilization load record: date, sterilizer identifier, load or cycle number, contents, the person responsible, physical parameters or the printout, and the chemical and biological results. The high-level disinfection record, where chemistry is used: product, concentration verified with a test strip, temperature, contact time, date, and the person who performed it. And the reprocessing training record, since the college expects designated staff trained for the volume and complexity of what the clinic reprocesses.
Two more items belong in the same file even though they are not logs. The preventive maintenance record for the sterilizer, because a qualification report without a service history does not show that the machine was maintained between qualifications. And the policy that states which instruments are critical, semicritical and noncritical in this specific clinic, because a classification list written for a hospital is not a classification list for a skin clinic, and the inspector will ask which one the staff are following.
What does the provincial college expect of the physician?
Ontario’s college adopted an infection prevention and control policy that requires physicians to carry out IPAC practices in line with Public Health Ontario’s infection prevention and control guidance for clinical office practice, and it identifies reprocessing of medical equipment as one of the high-risk areas the policy addresses. The accompanying advice document points physicians to the provincial checklist for reprocessing and sets out the classification table, the unacceptable methods and the expectation that equipment used to clean, disinfect or sterilize meets Canadian standards.
For a dermatology practice the effect is that the reprocessing decision is a physician-level obligation rather than a task delegated to whoever is free at four o’clock, and the documentation has to survive an inspection that arrives without warning. A 4 litre benchtop ultrasonic cleaner with dual frequency and a validated pouch system are the equipment side of that obligation; the written classification, the load records and the training file are the other side.
Where does a clinic take this next?
Four things a clinic can act on rather than read: a printable compliance log sheet that records receiving dates, lot numbers and open-on dates and exports from the browser; the clinic supply planner that turns daily bench counts into cases per month; and, where a finding has to be documented for an inspector, Ask your compliance question which returns a written answer citing the regulation or standard it rests on.
Facility and multi-site buyers can also ask about wholesale and multi-site ordering for case pricing and account setup. Reselling? become a distributor.
Related reading
- How should a dermatology clinic segregate biomedical waste in Canada
- How should a podiatry clinic reprocess reusable instruments in Canada
- What an infection control auditor checks about instrument reprocessing
Frequently Asked Questions
Do dermatology clinics have to sterilize instruments or is disinfection enough?
It depends on contact. Instruments that enter sterile tissue, such as biopsy instruments, curettes that break the skin and scissors or forceps used on open tissue, are critical and must be cleaned and sterilized. Semicritical items that contact non-intact skin or mucous membranes require high-level disinfection, with sterilization preferred. Items that touch only intact skin require cleaning and low-level disinfection.
Can a clinic reprocess a disposable biopsy punch?
No. Single-use devices are not reprocessed, and the manufacturer’s label is the instruction. The punch is discarded into a sharps container after use, and the clinic’s purchasing decision should reflect the fact that a reusable alternative brings sterilization, tracking and sharpness inspection with it.
Are glass bead sterilizers acceptable in Canada?
No. Provincial guidance lists glass bead sterilizers, chemiclave sterilizers, boiling, ultraviolet irradiation, microwave ovens and dishwashers as unacceptable methods of disinfection or sterilization for reusable medical equipment, regardless of what the unit’s own marketing says.
What has to be recorded for a sterilization load?
Date, sterilizer identifier, load or cycle number, contents, the person responsible, the physical parameters or printout, and the chemical and biological indicator results. The record exists so any pack can be traced back to a monitored cycle.
What has to be recorded when high-level disinfection is used?
The product, the concentration verified with a test strip, the temperature and contact time used, the date, and who performed the disinfection. A prepared bath that is topped up with fresh solution invalidates the record, because the concentration is no longer the one that was verified.
Does the physician or the staff member own the reprocessing decision?
The physician does. Ontario’s college policy requires physicians to practise in line with provincial infection prevention and control guidance and names reprocessing of medical equipment as a high-risk area, which is why the classification list and the training records are the practice’s documents rather than the cleaner’s.
Sources
CliniEco Medical distributes clinic and laboratory consumables in Canada under MDEL #35334. Requirements that bind a specific practice remain the ones in its own provincial guidance, manufacturer instructions and written procedures.
Last updated: 17 November 2026.