Cleaning Chemistry Test Data: What a Detergent Maker Must Provide and What a Clinic Can Ask For

Cleaning Chemistry Test Data: What a Detergent Maker Must Provide and What a Clinic Can Ask For

A technical data sheet arrives with a cleaning chemistry and says the product is highly effective against blood, protein and fats at low concentration. That sentence is a conclusion with the evidence removed. For a clinic the useful question is not whether the conclusion is true, but what has to exist behind it before the sentence is allowed on the page, and which of those artefacts the clinic can actually hold in a folder when an inspector asks how the cleaning step is justified.

CliniEco multi-enzyme ultrasonic cleaning solution, low-foam concentrate
The label parameters a clinic copies into its procedure, contact time and working temperature, exist because someone measured them; the file behind them is what this article is about.
CliniEco 4 L benchtop ultrasonic cleaner, dual frequency 32 and 48 kHz
The machine and the chemistry are validated together. A test report that names neither the machine nor the load configuration is not evidence about your process.

The distinction matters because cleaning sits upstream of everything else. A sterilizer cannot repair a soiled instrument, and no biological indicator will detect a lumen that was never cleaned. The chemistry a clinic chooses for that step, whether a multi-enzyme ultrasonic concentrate or a neutral detergent used in a 4 L benchtop ultrasonic unit running at 32 or 48 kHz, arrives with a set of numbers that were generated by someone else, in conditions that may not be yours. This article sets out what those numbers should be, and what to ask for when they are missing.

What a data sheet can and cannot tell you

A technical data sheet is a marketing and specification document. It can legitimately tell you the pH, the active enzyme classes, the recommended in-use concentration, the working temperature window and the contact time. Those are the parameters a clinic needs to run the process. What it cannot do on its own is demonstrate that the product removed a clinically relevant soil from a clinically relevant surface under the conditions you will use.

That gap is structural, not a defect in any particular supplier. Cleaning efficacy is a property of a process, not of a liquid: the soil, the surface, the mechanical action, the temperature, the concentration, the contact time and the rinse all contribute, and a test that changes any of them measures a different thing. This is why the standards separate what a chemistry supplier claims from what a facility validates.

What does the ISO 15883 series actually measure?

ISO 15883-5:2021 is the part of the washer-disinfector series that deals with cleaning efficacy directly, and its scope sentence is worth reading as written: the document "specifies procedures and test methods used to demonstrate the cleaning efficacy of washer-disinfectors (WD) and their accessories intended to be used for cleaning of reusable medical devices." Two details in that scope matter for procurement.

First, the object being tested is the washer-disinfector and its accessories, not the bottle of chemistry on its own. A detergent test report that does not name the machine, the load configuration and the test soil is measuring something, but not the thing your clinic performs. Second, the standard carries an explicit exclusion: it does not apply to the activities performed by manufacturers of reusable medical devices. Device cleaning instructions come from a different standard, ISO 17664-1:2021, which requires the device manufacturer to provide processing information covering cleaning and storage, among the other steps.

ISO 15883-1:2024, valid from 4 October 2024 and replacing the 2006 edition, supplies the frame around that: it specifies performance requirements for washer-disinfectors plus "the methods and instrumentation required for validation, routine control and monitoring and requalification, periodically and after essential repairs." ISO 15883-2:2024 covers machines using thermal disinfection for critical and semi-critical devices. Read together, the series says that cleaning has to be validated as a process, monitored routinely, and requalified after essential repairs, which is a different obligation from buying a product with a good data sheet.

Which nine documents should a clinic ask for?

The list below is what a supplier should be able to produce on request, ordered from the parameters you need to run the bath to the claims you are allowed to repeat. It is deliberately concrete: each row names the question the document answers and the answer that is not good enough.

Document Question it answers What a usable answer contains Answer that is not good enough
1. Technical data sheet with in-use parameters At what concentration, temperature and contact time was the product shown to work? Numeric ranges for dilution, temperature and contact time, plus a stated dose tolerance and the method of measuring the dose "Use as directed" with no numbers, or a dilution given only in capfuls
2. Efficacy test report naming the test soil and carrier What exactly was cleaned, in what form, and how was removal measured? Named soil, coupon material and geometry, machine and cycle used, number of replicates, pass criterion, and the method's limit of detection "Independently tested" or "laboratory proven" with no soil, method or criterion named
3. Dose-response data and minimum effective concentration What happens at 80 percent of the labelled dose? Removal versus concentration curve with the breakpoint identified, and a statement of the safety margin above it A single-point test at one concentration, presented as the label dose
4. Water quality envelope and rinse data Does it work in our water, and what does it leave after rinsing? Hardness, pH and conductivity ranges with test results at both ends, plus the rinse step and residue measurement after rinse Silence on water quality while claiming performance in hard water
5. Material compatibility matrix Which of our instruments will this attack? Alloy-by-alloy and polymer-by-polymer statement covering 400-series stainless, anodised aluminium, brass, plated surfaces, cemented joints and flexible endoscope materials, with exposure limits "Compatible with all materials and instruments"
6. Residue characterisation What is left on the device, and does it interfere with the next step? Residue chemistry, measurement method, and any effect on steam or low-temperature sterilization and on indicator performance No residue data at all, or residue discussed only as a rinsing instruction
7. Working-solution stability and use-life How long does a diluted bath hold, and when must it be discarded? Test basis for use-life, behaviour under soil load and in a warm bath, storage conditions for the concentrate, and discard criteria "Change when visibly dirty", with no time basis and no soil-load data
8. Safety data sheet in 16 sections What is in it, and how do we store and handle it? Complete sheet in the 16-section format required by the Hazardous Products Regulations (SOR/2015-17), with ingredient identifiers, WHMIS classification and storage conditions An abbreviated sheet, missing sections, or no ingredient identification in the composition section
9. Regulatory status and permitted claims Is this a cleaner or a drug, and what may we repeat to staff? Written statement of the claims the product is labelled for, and, where an antimicrobial claim is made, the authorisation that supports it Antimicrobial or virucidal wording on a product that carries no authorisation for it

Two of the nine are commonly missing in practice, and both are the ones a clinic can least afford to skip. The residue document is missing because residue work is expensive and rarely helps sell a product; the dose-response document is missing because a single passing test costs less to generate than a curve. A supplier who can produce both is telling you something about how the rest of the file was built.

How do the standards divide the responsibility?

The reason a clinic cannot simply demand that a supplier "validate the cleaning process" is that the obligations sit with different parties, and the split is visible in the documents themselves.

Source What it requires Who it binds What the clinic therefore asks for
ISO 15883-5:2021 Procedures and test methods for demonstrating the cleaning efficacy of washer-disinfectors and accessories Machine makers, test houses, facilities validating their own process A test report that names the method, the soil and the machine configuration used
ISO 15883-1:2024 Performance requirements plus validation, routine control, monitoring and requalification, including after essential repairs Facility and machine supplier jointly Cycle validation and requalification records; a change-control rule for chemistry changes
ISO 17664-1:2021 Processing information from the device manufacturer, including cleaning and storage Device manufacturer The device instructions that constrain which chemistry and method you may use at all
CSA Z314:23, clauses 7.3, 11.1.2, 11.6.1.3 and 11.6.3 Detergents and enzymatic cleaners prepared and used according to the manufacturer's instructions, covering concentration, temperature and contact time, with instructions covering mixing or dilution, rinsing and shelf life or expiry Facility A written instruction set complete enough to be filed and audited; a copy kept where the product is decanted
CSA Z314:23, clause 11.6.3.4.1 Containers of detergent or enzymatic cleaner are not replenished by adding new solution to the existing solution Facility A discard-and-remake routine that the batch record can show was followed
CSA Z314:23, clause 11.6.4.5 Solutions discarded when visibly soiled, after each endoscope or batch of respiratory equipment, and at the end of each shift, with the sink cleaned Facility Discard criteria written into the procedure, with the endpoint defined by device type
Hazardous Products Regulations (SOR/2015-17) Supplier safety data sheet in the prescribed 16-section format, aligned to the GHS edition named in the regulation Supplier and employer A complete sheet, plus a workplace label where the product is decanted

The Alberta Health Services review criteria that map these review items to CSA Z314:23 also list cleaning agents that are not acceptable for instrument reprocessing: hand soap or dish soap, low-level disinfectant wipes, surgical skin preparation solutions such as chlorhexidine gluconate or povidone-iodine, and any product not labelled for medical instrument cleaning. That list is a useful reality check on the substitution habits that appear when a clinic runs out of the product it validated.

How does this connect to residue testing?

Cleaning verification in a clinic usually means a residue test: a protein-residue swab, a total organic carbon measurement, or an enzymatic indicator read after the wash step. These tests are how a facility shows that its process, as run by its staff on its machine with its chemistry, reaches the cleaning endpoint its procedure sets.

Three things have to line up for that test to mean anything. The method's limit of detection has to be lower than the acceptance criterion, or the test cannot distinguish a pass from a fail near the line. The sampling has to reach the places soil actually accumulates, which for a hinged instrument means the hinge and the box lock, not the flat handle that wipes clean. And the criterion has to come from somewhere written: the facility's procedure, its provincial guidance or its quality programme. A residue result with no stated criterion is a number, not a finding.

This is where the supplier's documents earn their place. A residue document tells you what the chemistry leaves behind and how it was measured; a dose-response document tells you how far your staff can drift from the label dose before the cleaning step degrades. Without them, an unexpectedly high residue reading has two candidate causes, the chemistry and the process, and no way to separate them.

What should the clinic write into its own procedure?

The documents above are inputs; the procedure is the output, and it is what an inspector reads. A procedure that survives contact with a busy day usually contains the following, in this order.

  • The product identity and the exact in-use concentration, temperature and contact time, transcribed from the supplier's instructions rather than remembered.
  • How the dose is measured and who records it, because a dilution that is estimated is not a controlled parameter.
  • The water source used to make up the bath, and what happens when water quality changes, for example after a building works period.
  • The discard rule: when the bath is changed, that fresh solution is never added to a used bath, and how the change is recorded.
  • The compatibility check against device instructions, with a named person responsible when a new instrument type arrives.
  • The cleaning verification method, its sampling locations and its acceptance criterion.
  • The change-control rule: what happens to validation when the chemistry, the concentration or the machine changes.

None of this requires a laboratory. It requires that the four numbers the supplier already knows, concentration, temperature, contact time and use-life, are written down in one place, alongside the rules the facility has chosen to follow them.

Which answers are red flags?

Five responses should stop a purchase decision long enough for a second question.

  • A claimed contact time with no test soil named, because the claim cannot be reproduced or compared with anything.
  • "Compatible with all materials", because instrument instructions sometimes prohibit the chemistry a supplier claims to be universal.
  • Efficacy data generated only on clean, flat coupons, because soil removal from a hinge is a different problem from soil removal from a plate.
  • A safety data sheet with sections missing, since the sheet is a legal document in Canada and an incomplete one is a supplier problem you inherit.
  • Antimicrobial wording on a product with no authorisation to make that claim, which turns a cleaning purchase into a regulatory one.

The thread running through all five is the same. A supplier who can answer questions about soil, method and dose is describing a process. A supplier who can only describe a product is asking the clinic to take the rest on trust.

Where does a clinic take this next?

Four things a clinic can act on rather than read: a printable compliance log sheet that records receiving dates, lot numbers and open-on dates and exports from the browser; the clinic supply planner that turns daily bench counts into cases per month; and, where a finding has to be documented for an inspector, Ask your compliance question which returns a written answer citing the regulation or standard it rests on.

Facility and multi-site buyers can also ask about wholesale and multi-site ordering for case pricing and account setup. Reselling? become a distributor.

Related reading

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a safety data sheet enough documentation for a cleaning chemistry?

No. A safety data sheet is a hazard communication document in the 16-section format required by the Hazardous Products Regulations, and it tells you what is in the product and how to handle it. It says nothing about cleaning efficacy, dose tolerance, residue or material compatibility. Treat it as one of nine documents, not as the file.

What is a test soil, and why does its name matter?

A test soil is the challenge material applied to a surface before cleaning, for example a blood or protein-based soil prepared to a defined recipe. ISO 15883-5:2021 is the part of the washer-disinfector series that sets out procedures and test methods for demonstrating cleaning efficacy. If a supplier's claim does not name the soil, the carrier and the method, the claim cannot be reproduced, compared or audited, and it tells you nothing about the soil your instruments actually carry.

Can we switch detergents without revalidating the cleaning step?

The chemistry is part of the validated process, so a change of product, concentration or contact time is a change to the process. ISO 15883-1:2024 places validation, routine control and requalification on the facility and machine supplier, and a change of process chemical belongs in your change control, followed by verification that the cleaning endpoint is still reached. The practical test is simple: after the switch, does your residue method still pass at the sampling locations that mattered before?

Our supplier says the product has been independently tested. Is that enough?

Not by itself. Independent testing is a starting point, but the clinic needs to know what was tested, against which soil, on which material, in which machine configuration and against which pass criterion. A test report that names all four can be filed as evidence. A statement that testing happened cannot.

How do we keep the dilution right in a busy clinic?

Measure it, record it and never add new solution to an existing bath. CSA Z314:23 clause 11.6.3.4.1 is explicit that new solution is never added to existing solution, and clause 11.6.4.5 sets the discard points at visibly soiled, after each endoscope or batch of respiratory equipment, and at the end of each shift. An estimated dilution is an uncontrolled parameter, which is why the dose tolerance in the supplier's data sheet matters.

Can we use dish soap if we run out of the validated detergent?

Not for instrument reprocessing. The review criteria that map to CSA Z314:23 list hand soap, dish soap, low-level disinfectant wipes, surgical skin preparation solutions and any product not labelled for medical instrument cleaning as unacceptable cleaning agents. The substitution also breaks the link between your validated process and what was actually run, which is the part an inspector can see in the batch record.

What residue limit should we set?

One you can measure. The acceptance criterion belongs in the facility's written procedure, and it has to be reachable by the method in use, which means the method's limit of detection must be lower than the limit. Ask the chemistry supplier for its residue characterisation and the method used, and ask the test supplier for its detection limit, then set the criterion in between rather than at the edge of either.

Sources

- ISO 15883-5:2021, Washer-disinfectors, Part 5: performance requirements and test method criteria for demonstrating cleaning efficacy, valid from 30 July 2021 (successor to ISO/TS 15883-5:2005) — EVS record - ISO 15883-1:2024, Washer-disinfectors, Part 1: general requirements, terms and definitions and tests, valid from 4 October 2024 (replaces the 2006 edition) — EVS record - ISO 15883-2:2024, thermal disinfection for critical and semi-critical medical devices, valid from 6 November 2024 — EVS record - ISO 17664-1:2021, information to be provided by the medical device manufacturer for processing, valid from 6 July 2021 — EVS record - Alberta Health Services, Medical Device Reprocessing Review Criteria and Supporting Standards (Rev 2024, updated February 2025), mapping detergent and cleaning review items to CSA Z314:23 clauses 7.3, 11.1.2, 11.6.1.3, 11.6.3, 11.6.3.4.1 and 11.6.4.5 — albertahealthservices.ca - Hazardous Products Regulations, SOR/2015-17, consolidated to 19 October 2026 — Justice Laws Website - Public Health Ontario, PIDAC-IPC: Cleaning, Disinfection and Sterilization of Medical Equipment/Devices in All Health Care Settings, 3rd edition, May 2013, cleaning section — publichealthontario.ca

CliniEco Medical distributes clinic and laboratory consumables in Canada under MDEL #35334. Requirements that bind a specific practice remain the ones in its own provincial guidance, manufacturer instructions and written procedures.

Last updated: 15 November 2026.

Vous travaillez déjà avec des cliniques ? Devenez représentant régional.