A recall notice arrives by email at 9:40 on a Tuesday morning. It names a product, a lot code and a date range. The clinic has 40 minutes before the first surgical patient is booked. Someone opens the supply cupboard, finds two boxes with a different code, and concludes the clinic is unaffected — without opening the drawer where the loose tubes live, and without any record that would answer the only question that matters: which patients were treated with product from the affected lot.
That is the failure mode this article addresses. Lot documentation is not paperwork for its own sake. It is the mechanism that converts a manufacturer's recall notice into a list of patients who need a phone call, and it is almost always the weakest link in a clinic's supply chain because nobody owns it. Clinics buying silicone scar gel this month can see the current 15 g two-pack and the reusable silicone sheet as the two formats in the range, and both raise the same record-keeping question.
What does a lot number on a silicone scar gel tube actually identify?
A lot number identifies a batch produced under one set of conditions: the same silicone raw material, the same filling run, the same packaging lot, usually the same date. It is the smallest unit a manufacturer can trace and therefore the largest unit a recall can be limited to. Expiry date tells you when the product stops being usable; the lot number tells you what it is, in the sense that matters when something goes wrong.
Two consequences follow, and clinics tend to get only the first one right.
The first is that lot numbers belong to the manufacturer's system, not the clinic's. A clinic cannot generate them, interpret them or infer anything from them. All the clinic can do is copy them accurately and keep them attached to the right delivery and the right patient.
The second is that the number on the outer carton is not always the number on the tube. Distributors repack, split cases, and ship mixed lots in one box. A receiving record that captures only the carton code can be worse than no record at all, because it looks complete.
Why is the clinic's record the weak link in the chain?
The chain runs manufacturer, distributor, clinic, patient, and every link except the last one is regulated. Medical device quality systems, including the requirements set out in ISO 13485:2016 (valid from 25 February 2016), require identification and traceability through production and distribution, and the standard's identification and traceability clause (7.5.8) is the reason a distributor can tell you which lots went where.
The clinic sits outside that system. Nobody audits a scar gel purchase the way a sterilizer is audited, so the record exists only if someone decided it should.
The gap becomes visible in three situations, all of them ordinary:
- A recall or safety alert is published naming a lot that was distributed in your province.
- A patient reports a reaction, and the question is whether the product or the technique is the variable.
- An insurer or a legal request asks for the products used on a specific date.
Health Canada publishes health product recalls and safety alerts in a public database at recalls-rappels.canada.ca, and the notices name the product, the affected lots or units and the action required. The database is not the problem. The problem is what a clinic can do with the notice once it appears.
What should be captured at goods receipt?
Receiving is the only moment when the physical package and the paperwork are in the same place. Five fields, captured once, do most of the work.
| Field | Why it matters | Where it usually fails |
|---|---|---|
| Product name and size | Recall notices are written per product and per pack size | Recorded as "scar gel" with no size, so a 15 g notice cannot be matched |
| Lot number, per unit | This is the key the recall notice uses | Outer carton code copied, inner tubes never opened until use |
| Expiry date | Determines whether stock is still in circulation when a notice lands | Written as month/year only, or omitted on split cases |
| Quantity received and remaining | Ties a lot to a stock level you can count | No running balance, so "we used it all" cannot be verified |
| Date received and supplier | Narrows the window when a distribution date range is quoted | Invoice filed, receiving record not created |
Two habits make the difference. First, open one unit from each carton at receipt and record the code printed on the unit itself, not the carton. Second, record the supplier's name and invoice number on the same line as the lot, so a query can be answered without searching two systems.
The scar gel format adds a wrinkle: a 15 g tube is typically dispensed across multiple applications for one patient, and a two-pack may be split between a treatment room and a satellite chair. If the two tubes from one pack are not recorded as a pair, half the usage disappears from the trace.
What should be captured in the patient record?
The chart entry is what converts stock data into patient data. For a product like silicone scar gel the useful fields are few, and none of them are onerous.
| Record | Content | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Product used | Name, size, lot number | Lot is the only field that makes a recall actionable |
| Date and site of application | Procedure date, treatment area | Ties the lot to a clinical event, not just a month |
| Quantity dispensed or applied | Tube issued, number of applications | Distinguishes "one tube issued to the patient" from "applied in clinic" |
| Who applied or issued it | Initials of the clinician or assistant | Allows a follow-up call to start from the right person |
| Any adverse observation | Redness, itching, delayed healing, product complaint | The only field that turns a supply record into a safety record |
For reusable silicone sheeting the same structure applies with one addition: the number of cycles the sheet has been through, because a reusable device carries a use-life question that a single-use tube does not.
Clinics that already run a load log for reprocessing equipment usually find that the same sheet design works here. The compliance log centre carries a printable blank sheet and a browser-based generator, and the field structure can be adapted to a consumables lot register without a new system.
How should a recall notice be handled in the first 48 hours?
Four steps, in order, and the order matters because each step narrows the next.
- Read the notice for the three identifiers: product, lot, distribution window. If any of the three cannot be matched against your record, treat the notice as applicable until proven otherwise.
- Search the register, not the cupboard. Physical stock checks miss product already issued to patients, in a satellite room, or in a staff drawer.
- Quarantine matched stock and stop dispensing it. Record the quantity quarantined; that number is what a distributor or Health Canada will ask for.
- Contact the patients whose charts carry the matched lot, using the practice's adverse-event and follow-up process, and document the contact attempt even when it fails.
The American counterpart to this flow is set out in the FDA's recall policy at 21 CFR Part 7, Subpart C, which frames a recall as the correction or removal of a product that violates the law and places the responsibility for notification and effectiveness checks on the firm. Canadian clinics rarely deal with the FDA directly, but the logic — a recall is only complete when the product is accounted for — is the same logic that makes a clinic register useful.
How do you keep this practical in a three-chair clinic?
The register only survives if it takes less than a minute per delivery. Three design choices do that:
- One line per lot per delivery, not one line per product. A delivery with three lots is three lines.
- A single shared location for the register — a paper sheet on a clipboard at the receiving bench, or one browser tab — rather than a folder per supplier.
- A monthly five-minute reconciliation: count what is in the cupboard, compare to the register balance, and write off the difference. Unexplained differences are the early signal that product is moving without a record.
Multi-site groups should go one step further and standardise the lot line across sites, because the question that follows a recall is almost always cross-site: which locations received this lot, and how much is left at each. A group buying wholesale and multi-site can ask for consolidated lot reporting on the shipment — one lot per shipment line, one packing slip per site — which removes most of the reconciliation work at the receiving end. Reselling? become a distributor.
Ordering for a clinic, a lab or a care home? Wholesale and multi-site ordering covers case pricing and account setup, and the B2B wholesale collection lists the lines stocked for institutional buyers.
Related reading
- Silicone Scar Sheets vs Silicone Scar Gel: Which Should You Choose?
- Buying Silicone Scar Gel in Bulk for Canadian Clinics: Sizes, Storage and Waste
- Silicone Scar Gel Cost per Gram: Canada Clinic Benchmark for 2026
- Post-Surgery Scar Care: A Canadian Clinic Recovery Framework
- How Many Tubes of Silicone Scar Gel Does One Patient Need?
- Silicone Scar Gel Wholesale Canada: Case Sizes and Cost per Gram
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a lot number required on silicone scar gel sold in Canada?
Product labelling obligations depend on how the product is classified and on the manufacturer's quality system; ISO 13485:2016 requires identification and traceability arrangements through production and distribution. From a clinic's point of view the obligation is simpler: record what is printed on the unit, because a recall notice will be written in those terms.
What is the difference between a lot number and an expiry date?
The expiry date tells you whether the product can still be used; the lot number tells you which batch it came from. A recall is issued against the lot, so a complete expiry record with no lot number cannot answer a recall notice.
Do I need to record lot numbers for products that are not implanted?
For implants the record is a clinical and legal requirement. For topical products such as scar gel the record is a risk-management choice — but it is the only way to answer a patient complaint or a recall notice with a specific list of people rather than a guess.
How long should lot records be kept?
Retention should follow the longer of your provincial record-retention requirement and the product's shelf life plus a margin, because a recall can be published after the last unit has been used. Where the two conflict, keep the record for the longer period.
What if the carton and the tube carry different numbers?
Record both, labelled as carton lot and unit lot. Split cases and repacked shipments make this common, and a recall notice may reference either. Recording only the carton code is the most frequent reason a clinic cannot determine whether it is affected.
Should the lot number go on the invoice or in a separate register?
Either works if it is searchable. The practical requirement is that one query by lot number returns every delivery, every remaining quantity and every patient record that used it. A register designed for that query beats a pile of annotated invoices.
Does a recall notice mean the product was contaminated?
Not necessarily. Recalls and safety alerts cover labelling errors, packaging defects, specification failures and unapproved products as well as contamination. The clinic's response is the same in every case: identify the lot, quarantine it, and account for what was already used.
CliniEco Medical is a Canadian medical device distributor operating under Health Canada MDEL #35334. This article describes documentation practice for information; it is not legal advice, and record-retention obligations remain those of your provincial regulator.