When the Autoclave Goes Down: Permitted Alternatives and the Documentation Trail in Canadian Facilities

CliniEco autoclave indicator tape, three-width set, used to seal packs and record that a load went through a cycle

A sterilizer that stops at nine in the morning does not only interrupt the schedule. It creates a short sequence of decisions that have to be made in order: what happens to the load sitting in the chamber, how the instruments needed this afternoon get processed, and what gets written down while all of it is happening. Canadian facilities have several permitted routes through that day, and each one leaves a different record behind. What follows sets the routes side by side, states the limits attached to each, and lists the paperwork that a practice assessor or accreditation surveyor will ask for when the dust settles.

Quick Summary: CSA Z314:23 requires a documented contingency plan for sterilizer shutdown, and the criteria used to audit it name three interim measures — cancelling affected procedures, transferring reprocessing to another department, and preparing devices for transport. Ontario's RCDSO standard of practice adds two practical routes for a dental office: a colleague or a dental supply company may lend a sterilizer while the failed unit is out of service. No route returns a sterilizer to use without three consecutive biological indicator results in full chamber cycles, plus three Bowie-Dick tests where the unit removes air by vacuum. Emergency routes are permitted; normalising them is not, which is why the United States guidance says in one line that flash sterilization is not to be used for convenience or to avoid buying more instrument sets.

The result that usually ends an outage is a biological indicator readout, and the read time decides how long instruments stay quarantined. In a dental or clinic setting the 24-hour steam biological indicator in 50-packs is the format most rooms already run daily, which matters because the requalification run and the routine run should use a format the staff can interpret without a new procedure.

What alternatives exist, and what does each one actually cover?

The routes are not interchangeable. Some move the load, some move the machine, and one of them — immediate-use steam sterilization — is not an outage route at all but a narrow clinical exception that gets reached for when the other routes were never planned. The table below compares them on the four things that decide whether a route is usable during an outage: what it can carry, where it stops, what it costs in time, and what record it creates.

Route What it can carry Where it stops Record it creates
Second sterilizer already on site Any load the unit is validated for; implants still need a biological indicator in the load Only works if the second unit is in routine use and monitored, not if it has sat idle Its own routine monitoring log; the failed unit's out-of-service entry
Borrowed or loaned sterilizer Same as above, once the unit is qualified at your site Unit is new to your premises, so qualification testing applies before patient use Loan agreement, installation details, qualification results
Reprocessing transferred to another department or facility Wrapped instruments, provided transport and the receiving unit's cycle are validated for them Contaminated devices must travel contained and covered; clean return needs its own packaging Transport record, receiving unit's cycle log, release decision
Off-site contract reprocessing Instruments that survive transport and the contractor's validated cycles Turnaround is measured in days, not hours; packaging must survive two journeys Contract, chain of custody, contractor's monitoring records, receipt check
On-site chemical sterilization Devices that cannot take steam and fit a validated chemical process Liquid chemical sterilants do not give a packaged, storable sterile barrier; rinse and immediate use follow the label Chemical process log, concentration and contact time, rinse record
Single-use sterile instruments Any critical item available in a sterile single-use format Stock depth decides how many cases can run; sterility depends on the pouch arriving intact Lot and expiry of each unit opened, recorded in the case note
Immediate-use steam sterilization (IUSS) A single item needed immediately, in a container intended for that cycle Not an outage strategy: no implants, no storage, no holding between cases IUSS log: reason, item, cycle, result

Two of these routes are written into Canadian documents by name. The contingency criterion used in Alberta maps to CSA Z314:23 clause 18.1.1 and asks for a written plan covering who is notified, how the problem gets fixed, and the interim measures — cancelling affected procedures, transferring reprocessing elsewhere, and preparing devices for transport (AHS review criteria and supporting standards, February 2025). Ontario's standard of practice is more specific about the borrowed machine: if a dental office does not have a second sterilizer, "a colleague may be able to assist or a dental supply company may lend one" (RCDSO Standard of Practice, Infection Prevention and Control).

Which route is permitted for which load?

The load in the chamber is decided first, and it is decided against the last negative biological indicator rather than against the last cycle. RCDSO's instruction for a positive result is to remove the sterilizer from service, review the physical and chemical records since the last negative biological indicator, and recall items from suspect loads back to that point for reprocessing. Instruments already used in the interval sit inside the risk assessment that follows, and the standard directs the practice to consult the College or public health rather than decide exposure alone.

Implants have their own rule that survives every route. A biological indicator belongs in every load containing implantable devices, and the load is quarantined until the result is known. AAMI ST79 states the same requirement and allows a documented medical exception for early release, with the biological indicator still incubated; the exception is not a scheduling tool, and the Alberta criteria say outright that early release of implants is not to be used to compensate for inventory shortages or scheduling problems (ANSI/AAMI ST79:2017, reaffirmed 2022 with Amendments A1–A4).

Chemical sterilization is the route most often described more broadly than the documents allow. It is a real option for heat-sensitive devices, and the contact times are long enough to rule it out for a same-day schedule: the CDC table lists 10 hours at 20–25 °C for glutaraldehyde-based formulations above 2 %, 6 hours for 7.5 % hydrogen peroxide, and 12 minutes at 50–56 °C for a peracetic acid immersion system (CDC Guideline for Disinfection and Sterilization in Healthcare Facilities, 2008, Table 1). Those are sterilant contact times, not total turnaround, and a liquid process does not deliver a packaged item that can be stored for later cases. AAMI TIR31 draws the same boundary from the other direction: process challenge devices used in liquid chemical sterilization are outside its scope (AAMI TIR31:2008).

What does the documentation trail look like, record by record?

A practice does not lose points for having an outage. It loses points for having an outage with a thin file. Ontario's self-audit form names nine fields for every load, and the same form asks whether the log book is kept for ten years after the last entry (RCDSO IPAC Self-Audit Review Form). The standard of practice puts the same retention period behind the log book and requires the daily operation of every sterilizer to be reviewed and documented.

Record Who completes it When it is created Retention and where it lives
Load log entry: date, sterilizer number, load number, contents, cycle, time, temperature, pressure, initials The person running the cycle At the end of each cycle Ten years from the last entry, with the sterilizer log
Physical parameters, printout or data log The person running the cycle Each cycle; checked at the end of the cycle on a unit with a recording device With the load log
Chemical indicator result, internal and external The person unloading Each load With the load log
Biological indicator result and control Whoever incubates Each day of use and each cycle type, plus every implant load With the load log
Out-of-service entry: time, reason, who decided Sterilizer operator and office lead The moment the unit is taken out of service Contingency file, cross-referenced in the log
Service report and parts replaced Service provider At repair Maintenance log; the self-audit form asks for service call dates
Requalification results: three cycles with biological indicators, plus three Bowie-Dick tests for dynamic air removal Whoever runs the tests Before the unit returns to patient use Contingency file
Recall and reprocessing record for suspect loads Office lead During the investigation Contingency file, retained with the log
Contingency plan activation: who was notified, what ran in the interim Office lead First hour of the outage Contingency file
Transfer or contract record: transport conditions, chain of custody, receiving unit's monitoring Office lead Each transfer Contingency file, matched to the returned load

Two entries on that list are the ones most often missing, and both are cheap to create. The first is the out-of-service time. Without it, nobody can later separate the loads processed before the failure from the loads processed after the repair. The second is the release decision for each load during the affected period: who released it, on what evidence, and whether it was quarantined. RCDSO allows release of a routine load before the biological result only on a defined basis: a Type 5 or Type 6 chemical indicator in each pack, or a single process challenge device containing such an indicator where the unit has a recording device, evaluated together with the cycle's physical parameters. The release decision has to be written down, not assumed.

The load log itself is easier to keep complete when the fields are fixed in advance. The compliance log centre runs the same field set in a browser, prints as a blank sheet, and does not require an account; the wider frame, covering loading, packaging, release and records across the Canadian, United States and European documents, sits at the sterilization compliance hub.

The tape that seals a pack is the least expensive part of the trail, and it is the part that physically ties a pack to a cycle. A three-width autoclave indicator tape set normally lives at the packaging bench, with the lot written on the log line rather than left on the roll.

CliniEco autoclave indicator tape, three-width set, used to seal packs and record that a load went through a cycle
Indicator tape tells you a pack was exposed to a cycle. It does not tell you the load was sterile, which is why the tape line in the log and the biological result are kept as separate entries rather than one tick.

How is a sterilizer returned to service?

The sequence after a repair is mechanical, and it is the same in the Ontario standard and in the American recommended practice. Ontario requires three consecutive full chamber cycles with biological indicators after inspection and repair, using a different lot number where possible, and a Bowie-Dick test series for units that remove air by vacuum. ST79 requires the same three cycles after a major repair, run in an empty chamber for units larger than 2 cubic feet and in a fully loaded chamber for compact units of 2 cubic feet or less, followed by three consecutive Bowie-Dick tests on dynamic air removal sterilizers (ANSI/AAMI ST79:2017, clause 13.6.4).

A borrowed machine enters the same logic, and this is the step that gets skipped during a busy week. ST79 places qualification testing after installation, relocation, malfunction, major repair, process failure and changes to utilities. A sterilizer rolled into a room it has never operated in, connected to a different water supply and a different electrical circuit, is new to that site; treating it as already qualified because it was qualified somewhere else is an assumption, not a documented fact. The paperwork is short — three cycles, results recorded, unit released — and it is the difference between an outage that is defensible and one that is not.

CliniEco Class 4 dual-indicator sterilization pouches, 200 per box, used to package instruments for transport and storage
When instruments leave the building for reprocessing, the pouch is what protects them on the way back. Transport packaging and the receiving facility's validated cycle decide whether the item is still usable on arrival.

Why can't the emergency route become the routine?

Because every document that permits an emergency route attaches a condition to it that a routine cannot satisfy. The CDC guideline states that flash sterilization is not to be used for convenience, as an alternative to purchasing additional instrument sets, or to save time, and it restricts the cycle to items used immediately, cleaned before the cycle, and monitored with mechanical, chemical and biological indicators (CDC summary of recommendations, section 13). AAMI ST79 defines immediate-use steam sterilization as the shortest possible time between the end of the cycle and aseptic transfer to the sterile field, states that the item is not stored for future use or held from one case to another, and requires it to be identified as IUSS in the record. The standard also warns that late receipt of loaned instruments should not be used to justify the cycle — the exact excuse an outage produces.

The Canadian frame is a contingency plan, not a standing procedure. CSA Z314:23 clause 18.1.1, as the Alberta criteria read it, asks for a plan for emergency situations; the language is about who is notified and what happens in the interim, which presumes a temporary state. A practice that runs on the interim arrangement for months has not documented a contingency, it has documented a different process that was never validated as one. The distinction shows up in a survey as a question about how many days the practice operated without a functioning sterilizer and what was used instead.

Where do Ontario, CSA Z314:23 and the United States baseline divide?

The monitoring interval is the clearest split, and it is the one most often quoted out of context. Ontario requires a biological indicator in a process challenge device each day the sterilizer is used and for each type of cycle used that day. The criteria mapped to CSA Z314:23 clause 16.5.8.1 read the same way: a biological indicator contained in a process challenge device is run each day at a minimum, for each cycle used, pre-vacuum and gravity. The weekly interval belongs to a different jurisdiction — the CDC guideline and ST79 both say at least weekly, preferably every day the sterilizer is in use, as the American baseline. A Canadian policy that adopts the weekly wording and presents it as meeting provincial expectations has not copied a standard, it has copied a sentence that means something else where it came from.

The record-keeping horizon is the second split. Ontario's ten-year retention for the sterilizer log is a provincial requirement, not a general one, and a facility in another province should check its own health authority's criteria rather than assume the number travels. What does travel is the structure: a load identifier that survives the outage, an out-of-service timestamp, a service report, a requalification series, and a release decision for every load in the affected window.

Ordering for a clinic, a lab or a care home? Wholesale and multi-site ordering covers account setup and multi-site delivery, and the B2B wholesale collection lists the lines stocked for institutional buyers. CliniEco Medical distributes its sterilization consumables in Canada under Health Canada MDEL #35334. Have a question about your own facility? Send it in and you will get a written answer specific to your setup, with the regulation or standard it is based on cited. Ask your compliance question.

Reselling or buying for a facility? become a distributor for wholesale and multi-site ordering.

Related reading

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a borrowed sterilizer be used the same day it arrives?

No. A unit that is new to your premises should go through qualification testing before patient use: three consecutive cycles with biological indicators, run in an empty chamber for units larger than 2 cubic feet and in a fully loaded chamber for compact units of 2 cubic feet or less, plus three consecutive Bowie-Dick tests where the unit removes air by vacuum. The reasoning is in ST79's qualification clause, which places testing after installation, relocation, malfunction and changes to utilities. A machine that was qualified at another address was qualified in another configuration.

Do we have to recall instruments processed before the failure?

The look-back runs to the last negative biological indicator, not to the last cycle. RCDSO's instruction is to recall items from suspect loads back to that point, to the extent possible, and reprocess them. Which loads count as suspect depends on what the failure was: a positive biological indicator, a failed chemical indicator, or a physical parameter that did not meet the cycle specification each produce a different window. The window, the list of items and the action taken belong in the investigation file.

Can a load be released while the biological result is pending?

For implants, no — the load stays quarantined until the result is known, with a documented medical exception available in defined emergencies under ST79. For routine loads, Ontario permits early release on a defined basis: a Type 5 or Type 6 chemical indicator in each pack, or one process challenge device containing such an indicator where the unit has a recording device, evaluated with the cycle's physical parameters. The basis has to be documented for each load; the permission is conditional, not automatic.

Is liquid chemical sterilization an acceptable substitute during an outage?

It is a permitted process for devices that cannot take steam, but it is not a drop-in replacement for a steam cycle. Contact times in the CDC table run to 10 hours for glutaraldehyde-based formulations above 2 %, and the process does not produce a packaged item that can be stored for later cases. Rinsing and immediate use follow the product label, and process challenge devices used in liquid chemical sterilization sit outside the scope of AAMI TIR31. For a same-day schedule, it is a slow route.

What is the first thing to write down when a sterilizer fails?

The time it was taken out of service, who made the decision, and which load was in the chamber. Everything downstream depends on that timestamp: the loads that must be recalled, the instruments that must be reprocessed, and the period during which the practice operated on its contingency arrangement. The Ontario self-audit form also asks for service call dates, which is why the out-of-service entry and the service report are kept in the same file.

Does a weekly spore test satisfy a Canadian facility?

No. The daily requirement — each day the sterilizer is used and each type of cycle used that day — is the Ontario and CSA Z314:23 reading. The weekly interval, at least weekly and preferably daily, is the CDC and AAMI ST79 recommended practice in the United States. Both statements are accurate where they originate; a Canadian policy that adopts the weekly wording and describes it as meeting provincial expectations is a documentation defect, and it is one of the recurring findings in this subject.

Already working with clinics? Become a regional representative.