What Should a Clinic Do After a Failed Bowie-Dick Test

A failed Bowie-Dick test means the load in that sterilizer is not released, and the first action is not to re-run the cycle — it is to stop and quarantine. The test exists to prove air removal worked before the load was processed, so a failure is a statement about the machine and the cycle, not about the instruments.

The consumable that produces this evidence is a CliniEco Bowie-Dick test pack, ISO 11140-5 Type 2, 6 per boxBowie-Dick test pack, ISO 11140-5 Type 2, six per pack, run before the first load of the day in a pre-vacuum sterilizer.

What does a failed Bowie-Dick test actually tell you?

It tells you that air was not removed uniformly from the test pack. The usual causes are a vacuum leak, a blocked or partially blocked drain line, a worn door gasket, an insufficient vacuum stage, or a pack that was placed badly or over-packed. It does not, by itself, tell you which of those it is — and it does not tell you whether the load was sterile. It tells you the load cannot be assumed sterile.

What should a clinic do immediately after a failure?

Step Action Record it
1 Do not release or use the load; label it and quarantine it Time, load contents, operator
2 Stop using the sterilizer for patient care loads Time the machine was taken out of service
3 Check the obvious: pack position, over-loading, drain strainer, gasket condition What was checked and what was found
4 Repeat the Bowie-Dick test on an empty chamber after correcting the cause Result of the repeat test
5 Run a biological indicator and hold the load until the result is read Indicator lot and result
6 Escalate to service if the repeat fails Service call reference

Can the quarantined load be re-sterilized and used?

Only after the sterilizer has passed again, and only if the instruments can withstand a further cycle. Repackaging is often required, because the original packaging has been through a cycle and its indicator has already changed. Practices that re-run the load without a passing Bowie-Dick and a biological indicator are guessing, and the guess is recorded on the same log they will show an auditor.

Bowie-Dick test pack, ISO 11140-5 Type 2, six per pack

How often should the test be run?

For pre-vacuum sterilizers the test is run before the first load of the day, on an empty chamber, with the pack positioned as the manufacturer specifies — usually on the lowest shelf, near the front, without touching other items. It is a daily check, not a weekly one, and it is separate from the biological indicator requirement, which monitors each day of use for each cycle type.

What does the record need to show afterwards?

The record needs to show that a failure happened, that the load was held, what was corrected, and what the repeat result was. A log that shows only passing results is a log an auditor will not believe, because no sterilizer passes forever. The failure and its resolution are the strongest evidence a practice can hold that its monitoring system is real.

Related reading

Ordering for a clinic, lab or care home? Wholesale and multi-site ordering covers account set-up, and the B2B wholesale collection lists the lines stocked for institutional buyers. Reselling? become a distributor.

Bowie-Dick test pack, ISO 11140-5 Type 2, six per pack

Keep the paper trail in one place: print the sterilization log sheet, generate a fresh one with the log generator, and when an inspector or auditor asks for the sequence, ask a compliance specialist to walk the records with you.

If your clinic is still running one spore test kit across several sterilizers, 24-hour biological indicator 25-pack and read a single cycle end to end before you set a par level.

Frequently Asked Questions

What should a clinic do when a Bowie-Dick test fails?

Quarantine the load and stop using the sterilizer for patient loads. Check pack position, loading, the drain strainer and the door gasket, then repeat the test on an empty chamber. Hold the load until a biological indicator result is read, and call for service if the repeat also fails.

Can a load be used after a failed Bowie-Dick test if it is re-sterilized?

Only after the sterilizer passes again, and usually only after repackaging, because the original packaging has been through a cycle and its indicator has already changed. Re-running the load without a passing test and a biological indicator is an unverified guess.

How often is a Bowie-Dick test required?

For pre-vacuum sterilizers it is run before the first load of the day on an empty chamber, with the pack placed as the manufacturer specifies. It is a daily check and it does not replace the biological indicator requirement, which covers each day of use for each cycle type.

What should the sterilization record show after a failed test?

That the failure occurred, that the load was held, what was corrected, and the repeat result. A log showing only passes is not credible to an auditor; the documented failure and its resolution are the evidence that the monitoring system works.

CliniEco Medical is a licensed medical device establishment (MDEL #35334).

Already working with clinics? Become a regional representative.