Case Review: What a Sudbury Clinic Changed After Two Failed Spore Tests

A four-chair dental clinic in Sudbury logged two failed spore tests inside a single month and could not explain either of them from the log sheet. The pattern only became visible once the two failure dates and the two operator initials were written on the same page as the daily air removal results. This is a short review of what the records showed and what the clinic changed.

The outcome was not a new sterilizer. The clinic kept both machines, tightened the loading routine, moved the incubator off the reception counter, and added two fields to a log it was already keeping. The second failure was traced to a handling error, and no failure has been logged in the eleven months since.

What did the clinic's records actually show?

The first failure was logged on a Tuesday. The sheet showed a normal air removal result at 8:10 a.m., four instrument cycles, and a failed biological indicator read at 4:30 p.m. The second failure came eleven days later, also on an afternoon read, also on the same sterilizer. Two datapoints is not a diagnosis, but it is enough to say the problem was not random across the week.

Two things stood out when the sheets were laid side by side. First, both failures followed a day when the sterilizer ran a heavy instrument load late in the afternoon after a light morning. Second, in both cases the biological indicator had been incubated alongside a positive control that had been prepared much earlier in the day. The control was fine; the sequence around it was not.

What was the root cause?

The first failure was a genuine process fault: a chamber drain screen that had not been cleaned, slowing condensate removal and affecting steam quality on the later, heavier cycle. That one produced a real under-kill and the load was recalled. The second was a false failure caused by reading the indicator too early, before the full incubation period had elapsed, because the afternoon read had been squeezed in between patients.

CliniEco Medical 24-hour self-contained biological indicator, 25-pack, used for process monitoring and re-verification after HVAC work in a reprocessing area

Both problems share a cause that shows up in a lot of small clinics: the monitoring routine was fitted around patient flow rather than the other way round. The machine was fine on the morning cycle and under strain on the afternoon one, and the reading step was being compressed exactly when the clinic was busiest.

What changed in the routine?

The clinic made four changes, none of them expensive. It split the late-afternoon load into two standard cycles instead of one heavy one, so the sterilizer was never pushed past the validated load pattern. It moved the incubator into the sterilisation room and set a fixed read time that does not depend on the patient schedule. It added a drain-screen check to the closing routine, with a tick on the same sheet. And it added two columns to the log: one for the cycle type actually run, and one for the read time.

Before After
One heavy late-afternoon cycle Two standard cycles, load pattern as validated
Incubator on the reception counter Incubator in the sterilisation room
Read squeezed between patients Fixed read time on the daily routine
Drain screen checked weekly Drain screen checked at close, ticked on the log
Log had date and pass/fail only Log adds cycle type and read time

How was the fix verified?

Verification was deliberately boring. The clinic ran four weeks of daily air removal tests and daily biological indicators on both machines, then compared the new log against the old one for the same number of days. The record count was identical; the difference was that every row now had a cycle type and a read time, so a gap or an early read would be visible on the page rather than hidden in the pattern.

A follow-up audit of the retained logs showed the two changes that mattered: no afternoon load exceeded the validated pattern, and every biological indicator read was timestamped at least the full incubation period after the cycle. Eleven months later, no failures have been logged. The clinic also kept the recalled-load procedure on one page, which is the part inspectors ask to see after any failure.

What should another clinic take from this?

Two failures in a month is a signal, not a coincidence, and the quickest place to look is the shape of the working day around the sterilizer. Load patterns, read times and minor mechanical checks are the three variables that vary most in a small clinic and are the least visible on a pass/fail sheet. Adding cycle type and read time to an existing log costs nothing and turns a mystery into a traceable sequence.

24-hour rapid readout biological indicators for daily sterilizer monitoring

Print the daily sterilization log sheet for the extra columns, and run the sterilization self-check to see whether your own read time sits inside the patient schedule. The sterilization compliance hub collects the related guides.

For consumables, the sterilization monitoring collection carries daily-format indicators and the 24-hour rapid-readout biological indicators many small clinics use for the standard daily schedule. Buying for several chairs or for a group of sites? Wholesale and multi-site ordering covers case pricing and account setup, and the B2B wholesale collection lists the lines stocked for institutional buyers. To test a daily schedule on your own cycles first, start with the 24-hour biological indicator 25-pack. If you would rather walk a specific failure sequence through with someone who reads these logs every week, Ask a compliance specialist. Reselling? become a distributor.

Related reading

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a failed spore test be a false failure?

Yes. Reading the indicator before the full incubation period has elapsed is a common cause of a false failure, especially when the read is compressed into a busy part of the day. A failed result should always be checked against the read time and the control before the load is written off.

What should happen to the load when a spore test fails?

The load is not sterile and must not be released. Quarantine everything processed since the last passing test, correct the fault, re-run the affected instruments, and record the failure and the corrective action on the same log page as the passing retest.

Does a heavier instrument load affect sterilization results?

It can. A load that exceeds the pattern the cycle was validated for changes steam penetration and drying, and the effect is usually larger on the last cycle of the day when the chamber has been in use for hours. Splitting a heavy load into two standard cycles is a low-cost fix.

What extra fields should a daily sterilization log carry?

Two fields repay their cost quickly: the cycle type actually run, and the read time for each biological indicator. Together they make an under-run cycle or an early read visible on the page instead of only in a failure pattern.

CliniEco Medical is a licensed medical device establishment (MDEL #35334).

Already working with clinics? Become a regional representative.